Community

The Barbarians as they have currently been released are pretty awesome. I am slightly concerned that the game developers might tone down the Barbarians due to their stating that it has become obvious that they are currently better than Fighters. I hope this does not happen, with a few tweaks I think the Barbarian class could become the litmus test for every other class (i.e. Is this other class as cool as Barbarian... No? Then improve it).

I see what is nearly a perfect template for Class Features at each level in the Barbarian Class. A class feature, feat, maneuver, or spell should be gained by every class at every level. Look at the Barbarian chart... perfect up to level 13 in this regard (Except that in character creation it has feats no longer gained after level 9...lame, feats should be gained at 1st and every 3rd level up through level 18).

Below is how I think Barbarians should be laid out for class features:
1   Combat Expertise, Iron Hide, Rage, Reckless Attack
2   Fast Movement
3   -
4   Feral Instinct
5   Fearless Rage
6   -
7   Feral Presence (See below)
8   Relentless Rage
9   -
10 Feral Reflexes
11 Regenerative Rage
12 -
13 Channel Fury
14 Feral Senses
15 -
16 Incite Rage
17 Unchecked Fury
18 -
19 Primal Might
20 Endless Rage

Level 5: Feral Presence
The wild nature in you is cleary visible and imposing to your enemies.
  Benefit: If not already possessed, you gain the intimidate skill. Second, you have advantage on checks to intimidate. Additionally, while raging, enemies that are within your reach and are of 3 Hit Dice less or lower must make a Fear Save or become frightened
- They must roll a d20 and add their Wisdom Modifier against a DC 10 + (Barbarians Strength or Constitution Modifier, whichever is higher). This roll needs to be made only once per encounter. If the enemy rolls a natural 1 on this check they are terrified and treated as stunned for a number of rounds equal to the Barbarians Strength or Constitution Modifier, whichever is higher.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So, Fighters need to be improved. They pale in comparison to Barbarians right now. I don't know if the additional features that I have listed are enough to make Fighters as attractive as Barbarians... but I think it's an improvement.

Fighter's Class Features
1   Combat Expertise, Fighting Style, Maneuver, Parry
2   Maneuver
3   -
4   Maneuver
5   Armored Reflexes (Medium)
6   -
7   Armored Step (Medium)
8   Maneuver
9   -
10 Focused Attack
11 Combat Surge 1/day
12 -
13 Maneuver
14 Combat Surge 2/day
15 -
16 Armored Reflexes (Heavy)
17 Combat Surge 3/day
18 -
19 Armored Step (Heavy)
20 Combat Surge 4/day

Level 5: Armored Reflexes (Medium)
You are not hindered in the normal manner by the armor you wear.
Benefit: The Max Dex Bonus to AC while wearing medium armor increases by 2.

Level 7: Armored Step (Medium)
You are not hindered in the normal manner by the armor you wear.
Benefit: Ignore the stealth disadvantage normally imposed by Scale Mail and Dragon Scale.

Level 10: Focused Attack
You can sacrifice damage for a sure hit.
Benefit: Once per encounter you can spend a martial damage die to gain advantage on your next attack. Additionally, any Martial Damage Die you spend beyond the first is rolled with the total being added to your attack score as determined by the higher of your two d20 rolls.

Level 16: Armored Reflexes (Heavy)
Benefit: You can add, Max 2, your Dex Bonus to AC while wearing heavy armor.

Level 19: Armored Step (Heavy)
Benefit: Ignore the stealth disadvantage normally imposed by Heavy Armor. Additionally, your speed is not penalized for wearing heavy armor.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I believe that, in general, all of the classes should follow a similar layout in regards to... Alright, I get a feat every 3rd level but I should be getting something cool, something worth Leveling Up for each level.

Shouldn't Clerics, at least "Priest" Clerics, have the heal skill?

Death and Dying: An optional mechanism to death saving throws could be that if you roll a natural 1... you die. Additionally, you have the option to not make a death saving throw on your turn but instead take 3 damage.

I'm excited to see Druids become available for the general playtest population (As we heard that they are currently testing them out internally and with a select few external groups).

List of Classes that should make the final version:
Barbarian
Cleric
Druid
Fighter
Monk
Rogue
Wizard
> Bard (I know it's a duh...)
> Paladin
> Ranger
> ~Warlock/Sorcerer (This Class, if included, should have subdivision based on the origin of their spellcasting power... Dragon, Demon, Devil, Planes, etc... the origin should manifest itself over the span of leveling up... similar to a mechanic that was in 3.5 for the dragon based class... The Dragon origin would end up manifesting as leathery wings, a tale, breath weapon, unarmed claw attack, etc... The Demon/Devil origin could manifest as horns, levitation, cold skin, a split tongue, increased charisma... The planes origin could manifest itself as feathered wings, a cone weapon x/day from hand(s), etc...

Ranger: In talking to a friend, we discussed Rangers from v3.5. I have always disliked Rangers in playing 3.5 because it felt like how good they were was far too dependent on the enemies being faced. If they weren't going up against a favored enemy they were kind of lame. The first few levels, half of what they got were feats that anyone else could get.
   It was a little sad to me because I always thought that the Ranger archetype character in stories was pretty cool. But in playing 3.5 if I had a desire to play that archetype of character I would just use the fighter class to make them. It seems like favored enemy should not be a core mechanic of the Ranger. Something closer to the shape they took on in 4th edition would be better. Have them dominate in their environment, whether it be woodlands, swamps, deserts, etc. Rangers have the potential to be awesome if done well.

Well I think that's enough for now.