Community

Interesting idea for a campaign setting. One suggestion might be to try to kitbash from a low-magic setting released for 3.5 - the Conan and Song of Ice and Fire RPGs originally written for 3.X have some useful non-magical scholar and godsworn classes that you can build on to replace Clerics and Wizards and the like.

You probably want to buff non-magical healing unless you're going for a WFRP-style grim and gritty fantasy game. Maybe allow Healer's Kit to be used during combat as long as neither the healer and the patient are either attacking or being attacked?

Well, in the absence of a Cleric, you're down 1d8+4 for want of CD, and another 2d8+8 for want of two CLW spells.  At 5th, and a total of 14d8 +32 at 5th for want of a full-on-heal-bot cleric.  You might want to bring in some alternative in-combat healing.  Healer's kit would help.  You might consider letting PCs use an action to spend HD in combat, like a 4e 'second wind.'

Of course, if there was a shouty-healing warlord it wouldn't be an issue...  

Aug 17, 2012 -- 7:54PM, fairytalejedi wrote:

Thanks for all the input. I noticed earlier this week that there's a Song of Ice and Fire rulebook at ye olde FLGS. I might have to have a closer look at that. Re: healing, I have an idea. You can use a second wind action in combat (no kit required) but you have disadvantage on the hit dice rolls. So a fighter who spent one hit die on a second wind would roll 2d10 and take the lower result (repeat if spending more than one hit die). On the other hand, using a healing kit (requires a short rest) grants you advantage on the hit dice rolls. Hit dice spent on second winds count against your total, so you can't double up by spending the same hit die as a second wind and at the next pit stop. But at least it gives an option to save your bacon in the absence of magical healing, and a little more oomph to healing kits. Does this sound workable?

That sounds legitimately terrible. It's like "yay I get to spend an action to heal an average of 3 hit points while having the biggest hit die in the game, when enemies deal 6 points of damage on an average hit!"

Hmm, scratch that then. I'll have to look at other options.

From what I've seen, the game is pretty low magic as presented.
When I think High Magic, I think Eberron, and so far, this has seemed to be running in the opposite direction. 
Even in so much that non-magical also means mundane and somewhat pedestrian.
Stripping out the 2 (now 4) casters will only leave a party crippled. There are better systems to run a game where magic is in the hands of not the pcs. This system completely falls apart in absence the magical healer (Healing Potions are expensive and sorta weak, and HD are of variable utility at best), even with a Cleric, you need the Healer Specialty to have reliable progression through plural encounters.

If you are heart set on running with less than half a ship, I would suggest adding a second wind feature that is significantly stronger than current hit dice, cheapening healing potions, herbs, whatever, and bumping starting hp back up to 1st playtest levels. Basically, you will need to strengthen mundane hp recovery to offset a lack of utility and healign options... unless you desire a high body count and single encounter adventure days.