Community

 
Jump Menu:
Pause Switch to Standard View Critters R Us: A Sentinel Druid Handbook
Show More
Loading...
Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:42 AM PST




Critters R Us


A Sentinel Druid Handbook




Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:42 AM PST

Overview
Sentinels are leaders that rely heavily on their animal companion, exceeding long buffs, and, frequently, a ton of summoned animals.   

So Why Play a Sentinel?

Here are some strengths of the Sentinel

Sentinels are critter masters - Like druids from previous editions, sentinels can have a ton of creatures on the board at the same time.   

Sentinels are relatively easy to build - Like many Essentials classes, sentinels are pretty easy to build.

Sentinels make leading look easy - Sentinels get a lot of auras, including one from their animal companion.  These auras naturally help guide your party to success, as your party mates will naturally move to take advantage of the auras.  For example, I've seen completely new players decide that they wanted to focus fire on a sentinel's desired target, not because they understood that focusing fire was beneficial, but because they wanted the CA from the wolf aura.  

Sentinels are hard to keep down - You are tough as nails from your great constitution and are, I believe, the only class that can still do things (via the animal companion) when sleeping, stunned, or even while you're unconscious or dead. 

Sentinels can help cover all roles - Sentinels are leaders built on a controller chassis, and have a solid dose of striker and defender  thrown in for flavor.


Weaknesses of the Sentinel
Sentinels also have some weaknesses

Sentinels don't get leader encounter powers -  Sentinel encounter powers are striker powers 



The guide will use the following rating system
Gold - A must have.  You're literally hurting your character if you don't take this
Sky blue - "Very Strong" - An exceptionally strong choice. 
Blue - "Strong"- A solid choice but nothing awe-inspiring. 
Black - "Average" -This is generally a fairly mediocre choice, or an otherwise good power with a noticable drawback.  Optimizers will try to avoid these, but in most games you won't notice a discrepancy in power level if you go with a few of these. 
Purple - "Weak" This option is weak, underpowered, or very situational.  These choices won't show up in most optimized builds.  
Red - "Very Weak" - Either totally overshadowed by another option, or just completely bad.  These kinds of choices are generally avoided.

The guide covers the following sources
AP - Arcane Power
AV - Adventurer's Vault
AV2 - Adventurer's Vault 2
D XXX - Dragon Magazine, issue XXX
DMA 2009 - Dragon Magazine Annual 2009
DP - Divine Power
FRPG - Forgotten Realms Player's Guide\
HFL- Hereos of the Fallen Lands
MM - Monster Manual
MM2 - Monster Manual 2
MOTP - Manual of the Planes
MP - Martial Power
MP2 - Martial Power 2
PHB - Player's Handbook
PHB2 - Player's Handbook 2
PHB3 - Player's Handbook 3
PHR: DB - Player's Handbook Races: Dragonborn
PHR: TF - Player's Handbook Races: Tieflings
PHH1 - Player's Handbook Heroes: Series 1
PHH2
- Player's Handbook Heroes: Series 2
PP - Primal Power
PsiP - Psionic Power




Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:43 AM PST

Party Role
Sentinels are leaders built on a controller chassis, with an additional touch of striker and defender.  Sentinels are one of the few classes in which all builds have clear leanings toward all roles.   


Leader -  Sentinels get standard healing capabilities, extremely long buffs, and party enabling auras.  This makes them effective primary leaders. 
Controller - Sentinels naturally control a lot of terrain due to their animal companion.  They also have access to normal druid at-wills and dailies, which gives sentinels a lot more control than normal leaders.  Although sentinels lack contoller encounter powers, sentinels can serve as a primary controller if desired. 
Defender - Sentinels, especially dwarven sentinels with bear companions, make solid off-tanks. All sentinels should have very good constitutions and a ton of surges (10-11 at level 1).  The animal companion, in my experience, tends to draw a reasonable amount of attacks, as it looks and acts like a normal animal (unlike a shaman spirit for example).  This means that a sentinel is spending their surges (to heal or resummon the animal companion) to save the party from doing it.  However, sentinels aren't terribly sticky, and lack the punishment of a real defender. 
Striker - All sentinels are stuck with multiple multi-attacking encounter powers, which are clearly striker powers.  A sentinel currently also has a choice between higher accuracy (Spring) and higher damage (Summer).  Both of these choices also lead to relatively decent damage.  A summoning sentinel will also have respectable personal damage. 

Baseline Mechanics
HP and Surges  - As sentinels have consitution as a secondary ability, they are tough and have a lot of surges (10-11 at level 1). 
Proficiencies - Hide armor, light shields, and some decent weapons and implements.  
AC - Constitution to AC, and a light shield will give you an 17 or 18 starting AC, which is good for a leader. 
NAD Defenses
- You get a +2 to fortitude, and constitution and wisdom, means that you will have a good will and fortitude defense.  These are the two most important NADs.  Shields also give reflex a small boost, which help shore up a sentinel's weak spot a small bit.   

Class Features

Acolyte of the Natural Cycle
- This is probably the most important distinction in sentinels.  Basically, you pick a season to draw your strength from, and this determines your animal companion along with some additional benefits
= Spring Show

 Spring is the more offensive option.  Spring grants you a wolf companion, a +1 to hit with scimitars, spears, and daggers, and a small heal bonus.  The Alsfair Spear also is usable as an implement, so the +1 to hit can be applied to both weapon and implement attacks. 

The wolf is fast, and has a better AC than the bear.  The wolf has an aura that makes any enemy adjacent to it grant combat advatage to the whole party, regardless of whether the party member is melee or ranged.  This makes you, and the rest of your party exceedingly accurate, which means your party will do significantly higher damage per round if you choose the wolf.  The wolf aura also strongly encourages the party to focus fire on whatever the wolf is adjacent to, so it makes combat more efficient without requiring the party to make a conscious plan.   Also, if you have a rogue in the party, your animal companion gets a lackey


= Summer Show
Summer is the more defensive option.  This grants you a bear companion, a damage boost with weapon attacks using a mace or staff, and a small bonus to athletics.  Many sentinels of summer will use the staff, so they can easily use implement and weapon attacks, and also gain reach 1 from the Staff Expertise feat.  This allows the sentinel of summer to attack from behind the bear

The bear has normal speed, and a lower AC than the wolf.  The bear has an aura that increases all the defenses of adjacent allies by 2.  This makes the bear a particularly tempting target, and great to place next to the party defender.  However, this forces party members to choose between flanking with the bear, and getting a defense bonus.     

 


Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:43 AM PST

Ability Scores
Wisdom and constitution are your two primary abilities.  You get a lot of use out of both

Strength
- Although you like to play with beasts, being beastly doesn't give you a lot of benefits.  However, you could use a melee basic attack, a better shield, and multi-classing into strength based classes such as fighter. (Recommended: 10-13)


Constitution - This controls your HP, your surges, your AC, your animal companion's damage, your animal companion's HP, and some druid rider effects.  (I strongly recommend a 16 before racials, but anything 14 or higher before racials also is workable)


Dexterity - This controls your iniative, your reflex defense, and a few skills.  (Recommended: 10-13 before racials)


Intelligence - You don't have ritual casting, so this is a potential dump stat. (Recommended: 8-12 before racials)


Wisdom - This is the a sentinel's primary ability, and controls your attack bonus (but not your animal companion's), your damage, your animal companion's damage, and some important skills.  As sentinels get so much out of constitution I don't recommend going all out and getting a preracial 18 in wisdom.  However, a preracial 18 is always an option.  (Recommended: 16 before racials, but anything higher is also workable)


Charisma - Unless you want to be a party face, this is a potential dump stat (Recommended: 8-10)



Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:43 AM PST

Alien290 has another guide devoted to druids of all kinds, including the sentinel.  I am abandonning this guide, as I don't think we really need two guides and he is farther along. 

So please do not expect updates on this thread.

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:48 AM PST

Reserved5

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:48 AM PST

Reserved6

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:48 AM PST

Reserved 7

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:49 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 8:50 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 9:55 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 9:55 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 9:55 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 9:55 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 9:55 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 10:07 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 10:07 AM PST

Reserved

Flag furious_kender November 8, 2010 10:08 AM PST

Ok, I think I've reserved enough.  Please feel free to post away.

Flag embertiger November 8, 2010 12:10 PM PST
Looking forward to it.   The sentinel seems like an extremely flexible class and it'd be cool to see some perspective on different builds.
Flag alien270 November 8, 2010 1:26 PM PST
Sheesh, the book's not even officially out yet and you're already starting a guide!  I feel like this is just going to make me more impatient as I wait for my copy.

Anyways, I'm definitely looking forward to this class more than any of the other E-classes (big surprise there, if you're familiar with my posting history Tongue out).  Can't wait to see your take on it! 

EDIT:  I'll also be interested to see your opinion of the Wolf vs Bear companion (and as much as I like them both, I'll be anticipating Dragon articles detailing Autumn and Winter Sentinals). 
Flag Cyvaris November 9, 2010 5:48 AM PST
I too am waiting to see how well the Sentinel is able to cover multiple rolls. Wonder what bonuses they will give the other two builds.
Flag Corwynn November 9, 2010 11:19 AM PST
I'll be honest, I'm not really seeing Sentinel druids as being "blue" (strong) Defenders.  I get what you're saying about them being non-traditional defenders (they're damage sponges), but they're not sticky, they have no punishment, and they (seem) to have low-to-regular defenses (and hence will be affected by statuses).  So I personally wouldn't consider them anywhere close to actual defenders, who would be blue to sky-blue.

For example a cleric can have a ton of surges, regular defenses, gives buffs, and gets attacked a lot (mine does anyways, lol!), but I don't consider him a Defender

I also look forward to seeing their DPR at all levels, and hence being able to better judge their Striker potential.
Flag furious_kender November 9, 2010 11:40 AM PST

Nov 9, 2010 -- 11:19AM, Corwynn wrote:

I'll be honest, I'm not really seeing Sentinel druids as being "blue" (strong) Defenders.  I get what you're saying about them being non-traditional defenders (they're damage sponges), but they're not sticky, they have no punishment, and they (seem) to have low-to-regular defenses (and hence will be affected by statuses).  So I personally wouldn't consider them anywhere close to actual defenders, who would be blue to sky-blue.

For example a cleric can have a ton of surges, regular defenses, gives buffs, and gets attacked a lot (mine does anyways, lol!), but I don't consider him a Defender

I also look forward to seeing their DPR at all levels, and hence being able to better judge their Striker potential.




Yeah, I rewrote that section as I didn't rate that as clearly as I should of.  They are good off-tanks, as both they and their animals get attacked and they have very good surge economy. When the animal companion dies, they spend a surge, which they have a lot off, and it comes back as a minor action.  I've done this as many as 5 times in the same encounter...and no I didn't even come close to running out of surges. 

Sentinels are hard to stop by conditions.  For example, if you're immobilized, your animal companion probably isn't. If you're unconscious or stunned, your animal companion is still probably functional.   I've also had my wolf dazed, immobilized and with on-going damage at the same time, but my character was fine, so I just continued to attack as normal.   The same thing goes for most attack penalties. 

A sentinel with a con race will have a warden-level AC of 18 at level 1, and 11 surges. 

You are right though that they aren't sticky in the conventional sense, but they control so many squares of combat, that it's hard to get away from them using shift+charge without taking at least one OA.  Plus the rest of the party tends to stick close to your animal to to take advantage of the aura, so I haven't see much monster shifting to get the squishies with my sentinel. 

I've generally found that DMs find the auras to be annoying enough that they want to attack my Wolf animal companion, and I expect the Bear companion to potentially be an even more attractive target as it has an inverse defender aura that buffs the defenses of adjacent allies.   

  

Flag alien270 November 9, 2010 1:07 PM PST

Nov 8, 2010 -- 8:42AM, furious_kender wrote:


Sentinels don't get a lot of awesome encounter changing powers - Sentinels funtion off a lot of relatively small constant benefits, and long lasting buffs.  As such, they have fewer uber, encounter- changing powers than other leaders.  However, because sentinels have so many constant benefits, parties need fewer encounter-changing powers than with other leaders. 




Now I know I haven't seen the book yet, but I'm going to have to disagree with this.  Well, perhaps it's true for the Sentinal as presented in HotFK, but luckily you can choose any previously published Druid dailies, and there are plenty of encounter-changing ones available.  IMO Druids and Invokers are pretty much tied for 2nd in having the best dailies (with Wizards obviously coming in 1st). 

Granted your encounter-changing powers will be controller powers, but then again Bards tend to be the same way.

EDIT:  That's a great point about Sentinals being naturally "resistent" to status effects given that you control 2 creatures.  It's an advantage that's tough to quantify, but potentially comparable to the Warden's Font of Life.  Of course the downside is that you can both get hit w/ an AoE for ongoing damage and end up taking "double," but the advantages far outweight this (situational) weakness.

I am curious though, how exactly does the action economy of the Animal Companion work?  Specifically, can you command it to move, etc. as a minor action (like a summon), or does it get to take a move action when you move (like a Shaman's spirit companion).  I'm assuming that it doesn't require a separate move action, as that would severely hamper its utility.

Flag Corwynn November 9, 2010 9:21 PM PST

Nov 9, 2010 -- 1:07PM, alien270 wrote:

I am curious though, how exactly does the action economy of the Animal Companion work?  Specifically, can you command it to move, etc. as a minor action (like a summon), or does it get to take a move action when you move (like a Shaman's spirit companion).  I'm assuming that it doesn't require a separate move action, as that would severely hamper its utility.


When you move, it can move.  Or you can stay still, and use your move action to move it.

Everything else, including OAs, eats up your actions.  If you want it to attack, it eats up your Standard.  If you want it to use a minor action, it eats up your minor action.  Etc...

It can act independent of you, but only if you're unconscious or if you are more than 20 squares away from it.  When acting independently, it only gets one action: 1 standard -or- 1 minor -or- 1 move (though it can still take OAs and free actions, but no immediates).  And of course it still has an Int of 2, so your DM may restrict it to what would be reasonable actions.

If it reaches 0 hp, it goes away.  To summon it back requires a minor action and 1 surge, and then it has your surge worth of hp.  Or you can decide to summon it back outside of combat during a short rest, in which case it eats up one surge but comes back at full hp (which is your bloodied value).

Flag Alanlichen November 9, 2010 10:07 PM PST
Speaking of Animal Companion OA, I really doubt how effective it can be. That kind of damage without any nasty effects sometimes could be ignored if the monster would have a better chance of locking down those on the backline (to prevent more dangerous effects). Though for an off tank I guess it would be to ask for too much (yet again, I doubt if it's really blue compared to those who get a much better time off tanking). You are competing with a whole squad of other classes who could off tank very effectively after all (it might be good off tank but whether it's great is debatable).

As for NAD, that Reflex is born to be abysmal even with a light shield (especially when both hide and class add fort instead)...but I guess it's a general problem for most primals who depends on two attributes heavily (to the extend of crazy) and without any heavy armor.
Flag furious_kender November 9, 2010 11:27 PM PST

Nov 9, 2010 -- 9:21PM, Corwynn wrote:

It can act independent of you, but only if you're unconscious or if you are more than 20 squares away from it. 




The text says "In situations in where you can't give commands to your animal companion, it can act independently."  There is no text anywhere that restricts the animal companion to independent actions only if you're unconscious or more than 20 squares away from it. 


Nov 9, 2010 -- 1:07PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 8, 2010 -- 8:42AM, furious_kender wrote:


Sentinels don't get a lot of awesome encounter changing powers - Sentinels funtion off a lot of relatively small constant benefits, and long lasting buffs.  As such, they have fewer uber, encounter- changing powers than other leaders.  However, because sentinels have so many constant benefits, parties need fewer encounter-changing powers than with other leaders. 




Now I know I haven't seen the book yet, but I'm going to have to disagree with this.  Well, perhaps it's true for the Sentinal as presented in HotFK, but luckily you can choose any previously published Druid dailies, and there are plenty of encounter-changing ones available.  IMO Druids and Invokers are pretty much tied for 2nd in having the best dailies (with Wizards obviously coming in 1st). 

Granted your encounter-changing powers will be controller powers, but then again Bards tend to be the same way.




Yeah, I think I am focusing on sentinels too much as leaders.

Nov 9, 2010 -- 10:07PM, Alanlichen wrote:

Speaking of Animal Companion OA, I really doubt how effective it can be. That kind of damage without any nasty effects sometimes could be ignored if the monster would have a better chance of locking down those on the backline (to prevent more dangerous effects). Though for an off tank I guess it would be to ask for too much (yet again, I doubt if it's really blue compared to those who get a much better time off tanking). You are competing with a whole squad of other classes who could off tank very effectively after all (it might be good off tank but whether it's great is debatable).




A sentinel isn't terribly sticky.  However, most off-tanks aren't terribly sticky, as they typically lack marks and retaliation.  Instead, off tanks like the sentinel frequently give motivation to beat on them, and have the ability to take the hits.    For example, the bear aura gives a defense buff that is equivalent to a mark penalty, but it isn't a mark, so it stacks with all defender goodness your party may have.  The bear also has pathetic AC, which means it screams "beat on me." 

At level 1, an OA from a dwarf will probably do 12.5 (wolf) or 14.5 damage (bear) on a hit.  As you control two creatures, you have twice the opportunities for OAs as a normal character, with the exception that the same creature can't provoke twice in the same turn.  DMs are free to ignore this, but that damage will add up.  

A sentinel also simply occupies a lot of ground, which prevents the enemies from moving around you easily.  For example, my mounted dwarven sentinel/shaman occupies 6 squares without using any powers. 
 

Flag crayne November 10, 2010 4:05 AM PST
sentinel/shaman? There are no hybrid rules for the new essentials classes yet, or are there? But if you could create a hybrid sentinal/beastmaster ranger with MC shaman, it would be even more fun. With a mount, you'd have 5 figures on the board, that should be hard to kill.

I am also very curious regarding the animal comp. auras. Depending on their effects, they could be very pwoerful.

Edit: Does someone have a link at hand, to the dragon with the sentinels preview?
Flag Alanlichen November 10, 2010 7:52 AM PST
As for double the OA, does Sentinel have a decent MBA anyway?
Flag Corwynn November 10, 2010 7:53 AM PST

Nov 9, 2010 -- 11:27PM, furious_kender wrote:

The text says "In situations in where you can't give commands to your animal companion, it can act independently."  There is no text anywhere that restricts the animal companion to independent actions only if you're unconscious or more than 20 squares away from it.


I didn't make them up, honest

I'll give you the page number when I get home tonight.

Flag dleto November 10, 2010 9:52 AM PST

Nov 10, 2010 -- 7:53AM, Corwynn wrote:

Nov 9, 2010 -- 11:27PM, furious_kender wrote:

The text says "In situations in where you can't give commands to your animal companion, it can act independently."  There is no text anywhere that restricts the animal companion to independent actions only if you're unconscious or more than 20 squares away from it.


I didn't make them up, honest

I'll give you the page number when I get home tonight.




The relevant text is from HotFK pgs. 90-91.

"In situations where you can't give commands to your animal companion, it can act independently. For example, if you are unconscious or if you are more than 20 squares away from your companion, it doesn't sit around waiting for you to show up (unless that's what you have previously commanded it to do). An animal companion acting independently can take either a standard, a move, or a minor action on its turn. It can also take opportunity actions and free actions, but it cannot immediate actions."

Flag Mand12 November 10, 2010 10:00 AM PST
I thought this was going to be about a different type of crit
Flag furious_kender November 10, 2010 10:57 AM PST

Nov 10, 2010 -- 7:52AM, Alanlichen wrote:

As for double the OA, does Sentinel have a decent MBA anyway?




No, it doesn't get a decent MBA from a class feature.

Nov 10, 2010 -- 4:05AM, crayne wrote:

sentinel/shaman? There are no hybrid rules for the new essentials classes yet, or are there? But if you could create a hybrid sentinal/beastmaster ranger with MC shaman, it would be even more fun. With a mount, you'd have 5 figures on the board, that should be hard to kill.




Sentinel/shaman means sentinel MC shaman.  You can't hybrid essentials classes.

Flag alien270 November 10, 2010 6:09 PM PST

Nov 10, 2010 -- 10:57AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 10, 2010 -- 7:52AM, Alanlichen wrote:

As for double the OA, does Sentinel have a decent MBA anyway?




No, it doesn't get a decent MBA from a class feature.




Hmm, so basically Melee Training will be necessary for you to really take advantage of threatening squares adjacent to 2 creatures.  By default, Sentinals are kinda like Shamans in that the companion is the one that threatens, whereas your main character can't really make meaningful OAs. 

So the question becomes, how much of a priority is Melee Training?  Obviously it's nifty to threaten with 2 creatures, but it's not quite as crucial a feat as it is for other melee classes that can't make good OAs at all (non-BS Rogues, non-SF Monks, etc.).  Instead of it being one of your first feats, maybe pick it up by mid to late Heroic?

Flag Alanlichen November 10, 2010 6:20 PM PST
No MBA...well, that explains a lot...
Flag furious_kender November 10, 2010 9:37 PM PST

Nov 10, 2010 -- 6:09PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 10, 2010 -- 10:57AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 10, 2010 -- 7:52AM, Alanlichen wrote:

As for double the OA, does Sentinel have a decent MBA anyway?




No, it doesn't get a decent MBA from a class feature.




Hmm, so basically Melee Training will be necessary for you to really take advantage of threatening squares adjacent to 2 creatures.  By default, Sentinals are kinda like Shamans in that the companion is the one that threatens, whereas your main character can't really make meaningful OAs. 

So the question becomes, how much of a priority is Melee Training?  Obviously it's nifty to threaten with 2 creatures, but it's not quite as crucial a feat as it is for other melee classes that can't make good OAs at all (non-BS Rogues, non-SF Monks, etc.).  Instead of it being one of your first feats, maybe pick it up by mid to late Heroic?




I spoke incorrectly.  The animal attack is an MBA.  You yourself don't have an mba option unless you get mounted combat or melee training.   I'd go mounted combat before melee training personally, and use the mount's attack.  

One thing that I don't think can be seen by looking at them on paper is that you and the the party tends to follow the companion around to gain their aura benefit.  This makes creatures unlikely to move, as they will tend to face multiple oas.  

Flag crayne November 11, 2010 3:42 AM PST
The final version of the sentinel has not been released yet, has it? Maybe one of the sentinel builds will be able to use wild shape, so all the beast form basic attacks were good options (like savage rend)?

I just hope that they will modify the beasts basic attack again (or provide a viable option as at-will power for the sentinel), because it's damage scales horribly. It does not take into account any bonus damage the sentinel might have (items, feats, etc.).
Flag AlphaAnt November 11, 2010 4:31 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 3:42AM, crayne wrote:

The final version of the sentinel has not been released yet, has it? Maybe one of the sentinel builds will be able to use wild shape, so all the beast form basic attacks were good options (like savage rend)?

I just hope that they will modify the beasts basic attack again (or provide a viable option as at-will power for the sentinel), because it's damage scales horribly. It does not take into account any bonus damage the sentinel might have (items, feats, etc.).




People have had the book in hand for over a week now. There's only one build. That build gives you a choice of seasons to emulate, and the seasons are what chooses which animal you get.

No wild shape druids in HotFK.

Flag Metafictional November 11, 2010 4:41 AM PST
I'm not sure how optimal it is, but I see no reason why you couldn't simply ride your animal companion, especially in the case of a Halfling Druid.  If, as you say, both Druid and Companion have auras (I haven't looked at the class yet), then their areas would neatly overlap.

The only real downside I can think of is that you could both end up in the same area attack, but if your pet is faster than you are (the wolf should be pretty quick), it becomes a tactic worth thinking about.
Flag Cyvaris November 11, 2010 4:56 AM PST
Dwarf riding his bear companion?
Bear Calvary yeah we are so.....

Actually that could be pretty awesome, sadly the druid doesn't have an always on aura. Also with the sentinel being encouraged to be in melee if it did the aura's would probably overlap a bit anyway.
Flag crayne November 11, 2010 5:18 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 4:31AM, AlphaAnt wrote:

Nov 11, 2010 -- 3:42AM, crayne wrote:

The final version of the sentinel has not been released yet, has it? Maybe one of the sentinel builds will be able to use wild shape, so all the beast form basic attacks were good options (like savage rend)?

I just hope that they will modify the beasts basic attack again (or provide a viable option as at-will power for the sentinel), because it's damage scales horribly. It does not take into account any bonus damage the sentinel might have (items, feats, etc.).




People have had the book in hand for over a week now. There's only one build. That build gives you a choice of seasons to emulate, and the seasons are what chooses which animal you get.

No wild shape druids in HotFK.



It's out already? Strange, amazon.com lists November 16, 2010 as official release date.

I always assumed they would add wild shape to the sentinel, because of the wild shape errata...

Flag yesnomu November 11, 2010 5:31 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 5:18AM, crayne wrote:


It's out already? Strange, amazon.com lists November 16, 2010 as official release date.

I always assumed they would add wild shape to the sentinel, because of the wild shape errata...



B&M stores break the street dates all the time, it's one of their (only) perks over Amazon and the like.

The wild shape errata was necessary to make real druids actually work, since the OA ability among others is listed as an attack power.

Sentinels get plenty of class features without Wild Shape, and they're weapon-based (unfortunately so; bonking things with weapons seems utterly antithetical to even the 3.5 druid), so having two ways to fight in melee was unnecessary.

Flag alien270 November 11, 2010 5:43 AM PST

Nov 10, 2010 -- 9:37PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 10, 2010 -- 6:09PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 10, 2010 -- 10:57AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 10, 2010 -- 7:52AM, Alanlichen wrote:

As for double the OA, does Sentinel have a decent MBA anyway?




No, it doesn't get a decent MBA from a class feature.




Hmm, so basically Melee Training will be necessary for you to really take advantage of threatening squares adjacent to 2 creatures.  By default, Sentinals are kinda like Shamans in that the companion is the one that threatens, whereas your main character can't really make meaningful OAs. 

So the question becomes, how much of a priority is Melee Training?  Obviously it's nifty to threaten with 2 creatures, but it's not quite as crucial a feat as it is for other melee classes that can't make good OAs at all (non-BS Rogues, non-SF Monks, etc.).  Instead of it being one of your first feats, maybe pick it up by mid to late Heroic?




I spoke incorrectly.  The animal attack is an MBA.  You yourself don't have an mba option unless you get mounted combat or melee training.   I'd go mounted combat before melee training personally, and use the mount's attack.  

One thing that I don't think can be seen by looking at them on paper is that you and the the party tends to follow the companion around to gain their aura benefit.  This makes creatures unlikely to move, as they will tend to face multiple oas.  



Basically what I'm envisioning is the Sentinal and Animal Companion going after different enemies (prone archers, for example), creating a situation where through positioning alone you can lock down 2 different enemies.  Sure, your party is probably going to help out the companion to benefit from the aura, but by keeping enemy #2 out of the fight while everyone else beats down on enemy #1 you can keep some damage off the squishies, prevent enemy focus fire, prevent enemy flanks, etc.

In order for this tactic to be viable, you'll need melee training (or mounted combat, though personally I've never played a character that uses a mount in combat).  I wish that at least one of the Sentinal's at-wills counted as a MBA so at least you have the option of restricting your power choice or spending a feat.

Flag jedi123 November 11, 2010 5:45 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 5:31AM, yesnomu wrote:

Nov 11, 2010 -- 5:18AM, crayne wrote:


It's out already? Strange, amazon.com lists November 16, 2010 as official release date.

I always assumed they would add wild shape to the sentinel, because of the wild shape errata...



B&M stores break the street dates all the time, it's one of their (only) perks over Amazon and the like.

The wild shape errata was necessary to make real druids actually work, since the OA ability among others is listed as an attack power.

Sentinels get plenty of class features without Wild Shape, and they're weapon-based (unfortunately so; bonking things with weapons seems utterly antithetical to even the 3.5 druid), so having two ways to fight in melee was unnecessary.




Actually they have it because premeir stores get it early and are allowed to release it early.

Flag furious_kender November 11, 2010 7:34 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 5:43AM, alien270 wrote:

Basically what I'm envisioning is the Sentinal and Animal Companion going after different enemies (prone archers, for example), creating a situation where through positioning alone you can lock down 2 different enemies.  Sure, your party is probably going to help out the companion to benefit from the aura, but by keeping enemy #2 out of the fight while everyone else beats down on enemy #1 you can keep some damage off the squishies, prevent enemy focus fire, prevent enemy flanks, etc.

In order for this tactic to be viable, you'll need melee training (or mounted combat, though personally I've never played a character that uses a mount in combat).  I wish that at least one of the Sentinal's at-wills counted as a MBA so at least you have the option of restricting your power choice or spending a feat.




Well I'm torn about what kind of at-wills that would be best for a sentinel to have, as they only get one at-will of their own.  MBA at-wills are great for any non-strength class.  However, sentinels already have access to Fire Hawk, so they can lock down up to three creatures per turn, or more if some are adjacent to each other.  Sentinel encounter powers also are melee weapon+animal attack powers, so taking a ranged at-will, like Fire Hawk, still leaves sentinels with a lot of rounds worth of melee powers. 

Flag alien270 November 11, 2010 7:51 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 7:34AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 11, 2010 -- 5:43AM, alien270 wrote:

Basically what I'm envisioning is the Sentinal and Animal Companion going after different enemies (prone archers, for example), creating a situation where through positioning alone you can lock down 2 different enemies.  Sure, your party is probably going to help out the companion to benefit from the aura, but by keeping enemy #2 out of the fight while everyone else beats down on enemy #1 you can keep some damage off the squishies, prevent enemy focus fire, prevent enemy flanks, etc.

In order for this tactic to be viable, you'll need melee training (or mounted combat, though personally I've never played a character that uses a mount in combat).  I wish that at least one of the Sentinal's at-wills counted as a MBA so at least you have the option of restricting your power choice or spending a feat.




Well I'm torn about what kind of at-wills that would be best for a sentinel to have, as they only get one at-will of their own.  MBA at-wills are great for any non-strength class.  However, sentinels already have access to Fire Hawk, so they can lock down up to three creatures per turn, or more if some are adjacent to each other.  Sentinel encounter powers also are melee weapon+animal attack powers, so taking a ranged at-will, like Fire Hawk, still leaves sentinels with a lot of rounds worth of melee powers. 




Yeah, Fire Hawk is a really tempting choice for a Sentinal, and now that you mention it a good ranged attack would probably be ideal.  Plus it's thematic for any Druid that wants to focus on summoning other creatures to fight.  Unfortunately for Spring Sentinals with Implement powers, an Alfsair Spear is pretty much their only choice if they want to use a light shield.  Summer Druids have it easy, with a class feature that buffs staffs (far and away the best weapliment). 

I hadn't considered how Fire Hawk could allow a Sentinal to threaten 3 different widely separated creatures.  That's a lot of influence over the board, and as far as I know is unique to Sentinals (at least the ability to do it at-will)!

Flag yesnomu November 11, 2010 11:57 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 7:51AM, alien270 wrote:


I hadn't considered how Fire Hawk could allow a Sentinal to threaten 3 different widely separated creatures.  That's a lot of influence over the board, and as far as I know is unique to Sentinals (at least the ability to do it at-will)!



As much as a Melee training MBA can be considered "threatening" these days, anyway.

Flag alien270 November 11, 2010 3:00 PM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 11:57AM, yesnomu wrote:

Nov 11, 2010 -- 7:51AM, alien270 wrote:


I hadn't considered how Fire Hawk could allow a Sentinal to threaten 3 different widely separated creatures.  That's a lot of influence over the board, and as far as I know is unique to Sentinals (at least the ability to do it at-will)!



As much as a Melee training MBA can be considered "threatening" these days, anyway.



Yeah, true, but it's better than using Str...

Flag undergroundplayer November 11, 2010 6:20 PM PST
i do remember reading one more weapon for the spring sentinal, scythe or kama or something like that
Flag embertiger November 11, 2010 6:44 PM PST
Fire Hawk + Staff Expertise can do a decent impression of melee training.  Also, human and half-elf druids seem good just for the ability to get a second at-will.  Grasping Tide + Fire Hawk seems ideal for a human Sentinel.

Edit:

I think that the ability to use older druid powers through a staff should be taken into account in the rating of the Summer druid.  It gives it an edge over the Spring druid if you're looking to mix in implement attacks IMHO.
Flag yesnomu November 11, 2010 6:53 PM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 6:44PM, embertiger wrote:

Grasping Tide + Fire Hawk seems ideal for a human Sentinel.



See also: all druids. But yeah, the good druid at-wills might save this build.

Flag Corwynn November 11, 2010 8:53 PM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 4:41AM, Metafictional wrote:

The only real downside I can think  of is that you could both end up in the same area attack, but if your  pet is faster than you are (the wolf should be pretty quick), it becomes  a tactic worth thinking about.


Wolf animal companion is speed  8, Bear is speed 6.  Both are medium sized (so perfect for a  halfling)... or just use the Beast Growth ritual on it (lasts 8 hours,  70 gold)

A sentinel druid's animal companion is a "natural beast"  despite the fact that it's summoned from primal energies, so I believe  the ritual should work.

Flag Alanlichen November 11, 2010 9:47 PM PST
Or get a Jade Horse XD
Sentinel MC shaman with Jade horse would have 3 companions...
Psylock Marking Hand of Radiance, then put all three companions each near one of the target...
With Power of Moon or Cold with Frost Cheese...
Flag furious_kender November 12, 2010 10:31 AM PST

Nov 11, 2010 -- 6:44PM, embertiger wrote:

I think that the ability to use older druid powers through a staff should be taken into account in the rating of the Summer druid.  It gives it an edge over the Spring druid if you're looking to mix in implement attacks IMHO.




Spring druids, if they use a spear, dagger or scimitar as a implement, gain a +1 to hit.  If they're attacking something adjacent to the wolf, that makes it +3 over the summer druid.   Summer druids can get accurate staves, but that takes an extra feat and only applies to implement attacks.  Staves have better properties and staff expertise is also awesome, but the increased accuracy of the spring druid I think balances the two out.  

Nov 11, 2010 -- 8:53PM, Corwynn wrote:

Nov 11, 2010 -- 4:41AM, Metafictional wrote:

The only real downside I can think of is that you could both end up in the same area attack, but if your pet is faster than you are (the wolf should be pretty quick), it becomes a tactic worth thinking about.


Wolf animal companion is speed 8, Bear is speed 6.  Both are medium sized (so perfect for a halfling)... or just use the Beast Growth ritual on it (lasts 8 hours, 70 gold)

A sentinel druid's animal companion is a "natural beast" despite the fact that it's summoned from primal energies, so I believe the ritual should work.




I wouldn't count on wanting to, or being able to, use Beast Growth.  First off, you don't have ritual casting. Second, the animal companion in my experience dies a lot.  I think I've had my wolf companion survive through 1 game day out of the 7 or so game days I've played, and that is with me using dwarven second wind to heal it.  Most of the time, it dies 3-4 times per game day, and I've had it die up to 5 times in a single encounter.  As this was at low to mid heroic, I expect it to start dying more as I progress in levels.   In contrast, I also have a spirit companion, and it take WAY fewer attacks than the animal companion, and dies on average once a game day. 

Flag Lord_Ventnor November 12, 2010 1:41 PM PST
I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.
Flag furious_kender November 12, 2010 1:59 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:41PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.




Yep, I agree 100%.  The Alfsair Spear isn't bad for a weapliment, but it isn't all that good either.   Plus, you can get wisdom to you initiative with a feat from the new essentials book, so you could use dex as a dump stat and int for your reflex and some skills.

Flag Corwynn November 12, 2010 3:34 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 10:31AM, furious_kender wrote:

I wouldn't count on wanting to, or being able to, use Beast Growth.  First off, you don't have ritual casting. Second, the animal companion in my experience dies a lot.  I think I've had my wolf companion survive through 1 game day out of the 7 or so game days I've played, and that is with me using dwarven second wind to heal it.  Most of the time, it dies 3-4 times per game day, and I've had it die up to 5 times in a single encounter.  As this was at low to mid heroic, I expect it to start dying more as I progress in levels.   In contrast, I also have a spirit companion, and it take WAY fewer attacks than the animal companion, and dies on average once a game day. 


Wow, that seems high.  That's at least 5 surges as well... it's a surge drainer.

I would get Impenetrable Barding then if you plan to use it as a mount (with Beast Growth).

My ranger has had his beast companion survive almost all LFR scenarios.  When I beast growth it (it's a Raptor) and start riding it at level 5 (with Beast Rider), shooting arrows at my target while flying 20 squares above the battlefield, I expect the DM might start trying to kill it more though

Flag undergroundplayer November 12, 2010 4:27 PM PST
does everyone ignore
  the sythe sicce kama weapon for spring sents
Flag alien270 November 12, 2010 4:52 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:59PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:41PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.




Yep, I agree 100%.  The Alfsair Spear isn't bad for a weapliment, but it isn't all that good either.   Plus, you can get wisdom to you initiative with a feat from the new essentials book, so you could use dex as a dump stat and int for your reflex and some skills.



Is there any specific heavy blade enchantment that would justify spending a feat to be able to use scimitars as an implement?  I mean, the only difference between the weapons is that spears are versatile and scimitars are high crit; otherwise their stats are identical.  I usually just pick up a Farbond Spellblade with a Swordmage, and a Sentinel can't really use that (no Str to take advantage of heavy thrown).  I'm also not really a fan of Blade Initiate's benefit.

Flag Jay_Ibero_911 November 12, 2010 5:07 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 4:52PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:59PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:41PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.




Yep, I agree 100%.  The Alfsair Spear isn't bad for a weapliment, but it isn't all that good either.   Plus, you can get wisdom to you initiative with a feat from the new essentials book, so you could use dex as a dump stat and int for your reflex and some skills.



Is there any specific heavy blade enchantment that would justify spending a feat to be able to use scimitars as an implement?  I mean, the only difference between the weapons is that spears are versatile and scimitars are high crit; otherwise their stats are identical.  I usually just pick up a Farbond Spellblade with a Swordmage, and a Sentinel can't really use that (no Str to take advantage of heavy thrown).  I'm also not really a fan of Blade Initiate's benefit.




Well given the new rarity system, it saves you from needing a specific  weapon enhancement that you can no longer count on getting......Also heavy blade expertise is more useful for a sentinel than spear expertise.


Flag alien270 November 12, 2010 5:35 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 5:07PM, Jay_Ibero_911 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 4:52PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:59PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:41PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.




Yep, I agree 100%.  The Alfsair Spear isn't bad for a weapliment, but it isn't all that good either.   Plus, you can get wisdom to you initiative with a feat from the new essentials book, so you could use dex as a dump stat and int for your reflex and some skills.



Is there any specific heavy blade enchantment that would justify spending a feat to be able to use scimitars as an implement?  I mean, the only difference between the weapons is that spears are versatile and scimitars are high crit; otherwise their stats are identical.  I usually just pick up a Farbond Spellblade with a Swordmage, and a Sentinel can't really use that (no Str to take advantage of heavy thrown).  I'm also not really a fan of Blade Initiate's benefit.




Well given the new rarity system, it saves you from needing a specific  weapon enhancement that you can no longer count on getting......Also heavy blade expertise is more useful for a sentinel than spear expertise.



If the point is to use implement attacks, then neither heavy blade expertise nor spear expertise will do you much good; you're stuck with Versatile Expertise.

Yeah, I guess the rarity system is a wild card.  I'm planning on ignoring the whole thing, so I sometimes forget about it.  Inherent bonuses are also a good way to get around needing a specific enchantment.

Flag Jay_Ibero_911 November 12, 2010 5:48 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 5:35PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 5:07PM, Jay_Ibero_911 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 4:52PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:59PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:41PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.




Yep, I agree 100%.  The Alfsair Spear isn't bad for a weapliment, but it isn't all that good either.   Plus, you can get wisdom to you initiative with a feat from the new essentials book, so you could use dex as a dump stat and int for your reflex and some skills.



Is there any specific heavy blade enchantment that would justify spending a feat to be able to use scimitars as an implement?  I mean, the only difference between the weapons is that spears are versatile and scimitars are high crit; otherwise their stats are identical.  I usually just pick up a Farbond Spellblade with a Swordmage, and a Sentinel can't really use that (no Str to take advantage of heavy thrown).  I'm also not really a fan of Blade Initiate's benefit.




Well given the new rarity system, it saves you from needing a specific  weapon enhancement that you can no longer count on getting......Also heavy blade expertise is more useful for a sentinel than spear expertise.



If the point is to use implement attacks, then neither heavy blade expertise nor spear expertise will do you much good; you're stuck with Versatile Expertise.

Yeah, I guess the rarity system is a wild card.  I'm planning on ignoring the whole thing, so I sometimes forget about it.  Inherent bonuses are also a good way to get around needing a specific enchantment.




Well the benefit of Heavy Blade expertise is a +2 bonus to defenses against OA's, a handy thing to have even if using implement powers...

Flag furious_kender November 12, 2010 8:56 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 5:07PM, Jay_Ibero_911 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 4:52PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:59PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 1:41PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

I think it would be a good idea to note that Spring Druids will want a 13 Intelligence to pick up a Swordmage multiclass feat so that they can use Heavy Blades (aka Scimitars) as an Implement.




Yep, I agree 100%.  The Alfsair Spear isn't bad for a weapliment, but it isn't all that good either.   Plus, you can get wisdom to you initiative with a feat from the new essentials book, so you could use dex as a dump stat and int for your reflex and some skills.



Is there any specific heavy blade enchantment that would justify spending a feat to be able to use scimitars as an implement?  I mean, the only difference between the weapons is that spears are versatile and scimitars are high crit; otherwise their stats are identical.  I usually just pick up a Farbond Spellblade with a Swordmage, and a Sentinel can't really use that (no Str to take advantage of heavy thrown).  I'm also not really a fan of Blade Initiate's benefit.




Well given the new rarity system, it saves you from needing a specific  weapon enhancement that you can no longer count on getting......Also heavy blade expertise is more useful for a sentinel than spear expertise.




Blade Initiate gives you heavy and light blades as implements, arcana trained, and +1 AC for an encounter.  For a class that could conceivably dump dex, that's not bad at all. 

Heavy blade enhancements that are better than Alfsair Spear: Jagged, Radiant, Subtle (with the wolf you will have 100% ca if you want), and just about anything that melee people like.

The major downside of Blade Initiate is that other MC feats also are very nice, like Spirit Talker+Mending Spirit.     

If you use implement attacks much, Staff Expertise or Versatile Expertise are your only two real options.  Otherwise, you'll need two expertise feats, which sucks.  You can however make a druid that is melee only, but that would mean foregoing all the nice druid powers.

Flag furious_kender November 12, 2010 9:22 PM PST

Nov 12, 2010 -- 3:34PM, Corwynn wrote:

Nov 12, 2010 -- 10:31AM, furious_kender wrote:

I wouldn't count on wanting to, or being able to, use Beast Growth.  First off, you don't have ritual casting. Second, the animal companion in my experience dies a lot.  I think I've had my wolf companion survive through 1 game day out of the 7 or so game days I've played, and that is with me using dwarven second wind to heal it.  Most of the time, it dies 3-4 times per game day, and I've had it die up to 5 times in a single encounter.  As this was at low to mid heroic, I expect it to start dying more as I progress in levels.   In contrast, I also have a spirit companion, and it take WAY fewer attacks than the animal companion, and dies on average once a game day. 


Wow, that seems high.  That's at least 5 surges as well... it's a surge drainer.

I would get Impenetrable Barding then if you plan to use it as a mount (with Beast Growth).

My ranger has had his beast companion survive almost all LFR scenarios.  When I beast growth it (it's a Raptor) and start riding it at level 5 (with Beast Rider), shooting arrows at my target while flying 20 squares above the battlefield, I expect the DM might start trying to kill it more though




The animal companion aura is annoying to enemies and is powerful.  This has made all 6 DMs I've played with want to kill the animal companion in at least some encounters.  In several encounters against solos and really buffed elites, only the defender and my wolf dared approach them after the 2nd or 3rd round, as most everyone else was beaten to a pulp by auras, bursts and blasts.  The combats went like this, defender goes (typically dazed), solo kills wolf and damages defender, rest of party delays, I resummoned wolf, wolf goes in to melee, I attack, rest of party attacks.  Then it repeated until the solo was dead.     

Flag furious_kender November 12, 2010 10:43 PM PST
I was just about to upload another couple of pages, when I realized Alien is making a new druid guide just to incorporate the sentinel into the guide.  As he's farther along, and guides take A LOT of work to do properly, I think I'm going to abandon this guide to focus more on my monk guide.    
Flag gold_piece November 13, 2010 11:31 AM PST
I need to create a druid for Encounters.  Can someone tell me what races get a +2 to wis and con?  Thanks!
Flag jedi123 November 13, 2010 11:53 AM PST

Nov 13, 2010 -- 11:31AM, gold_piece wrote:

I need to create a druid for Encounters.  Can someone tell me what races get a +2 to wis and con?  Thanks!




Dwarf, Mul, and Half-Elf, Wilden I think thats all.

Flag Vael November 13, 2010 1:56 PM PST
And since you are limited to Essentials races for Encounters ... you only get the Half-Elf or Dwarf.
Flag gold_piece November 13, 2010 2:39 PM PST

Nov 13, 2010 -- 1:56PM, Vael wrote:

And since you are limited to Essentials races for Encounters ... you only get the Half-Elf or Dwarf.




Yeah, and my group already has two dwarves, so I'm going to be a half elf.  That should work fine.  Is the half elf in Essentials the same as half elf in PHB?  I don't have HotFK.  My D&D budget is spent for the month.

Flag alien270 November 13, 2010 3:33 PM PST

Nov 13, 2010 -- 2:39PM, gold_piece wrote:

Nov 13, 2010 -- 1:56PM, Vael wrote:

And since you are limited to Essentials races for Encounters ... you only get the Half-Elf or Dwarf.




Yeah, and my group already has two dwarves, so I'm going to be a half elf.  That should work fine.  Is the half elf in Essentials the same as half elf in PHB?  I don't have HotFK.  My D&D budget is spent for the month.



You can trade Dilletante out for a new racial encounter power, Knack for Success.  It's a minor action, close burst 5 that can target you or an ally.  You can choose 1 of 4 effects:  Make a saving throw, shift 2 as a free action, +2 to next attack roll before end of target's next turn, or +4 to next skill check before end of target's next turn.  IMO it's a better deal than Dilletante for most classes.

Flag gold_piece November 13, 2010 4:05 PM PST

Nov 13, 2010 -- 3:33PM, alien270 wrote:

Nov 13, 2010 -- 2:39PM, gold_piece wrote:

Nov 13, 2010 -- 1:56PM, Vael wrote:

And since you are limited to Essentials races for Encounters ... you only get the Half-Elf or Dwarf.




Yeah, and my group already has two dwarves, so I'm going to be a half elf.  That should work fine.  Is the half elf in Essentials the same as half elf in PHB?  I don't have HotFK.  My D&D budget is spent for the month.



You can trade Dilletante out for a new racial encounter power, Knack for Success.  It's a minor action, close burst 5 that can target you or an ally.  You can choose 1 of 4 effects:  Make a saving throw, shift 2 as a free action, +2 to next attack roll before end of target's next turn, or +4 to next skill check before end of target's next turn.  IMO it's a better deal than Dilletante for most classes.




Thanks Alien.  That's helpful.  Sounds pretty fun!

Flag Lord_Ventnor November 13, 2010 5:55 PM PST

Nov 13, 2010 -- 2:39PM, gold_piece wrote:

Nov 13, 2010 -- 1:56PM, Vael wrote:

And since you are limited to Essentials races for Encounters ... you only get the Half-Elf or Dwarf.




Yeah, and my group already has two dwarves, so I'm going to be a half elf.  That should work fine.  Is the half elf in Essentials the same as half elf in PHB?  I don't have HotFK.  My D&D budget is spent for the month.




How are you expecting to make a Sentinel Druid if you don't have the book that it's printed in? Wouldn't it be easier to make a character based off of one of the classes in HoFL instead (assuming you have that)?

Flag gold_piece November 13, 2010 7:53 PM PST

Nov 13, 2010 -- 5:55PM, Lord_Ventnor wrote:

Nov 13, 2010 -- 2:39PM, gold_piece wrote:

Nov 13, 2010 -- 1:56PM, Vael wrote:

And since you are limited to Essentials races for Encounters ... you only get the Half-Elf or Dwarf.




Yeah, and my group already has two dwarves, so I'm going to be a half elf.  That should work fine.  Is the half elf in Essentials the same as half elf in PHB?  I don't have HotFK.  My D&D budget is spent for the month.




How are you expecting to make a Sentinel Druid if you don't have the book that it's printed in? Wouldn't it be easier to make a character based off of one of the classes in HoFL instead (assuming you have that)?




Good question!!  I'm trying to do as much as I can by using the preview on the WotC site and posting on forums like this.  Then when I hit the limit with that I will borrow the book from a friend and round things out.  I already have HoFL but I want to try something a little different. 

Flag undergroundplayer November 15, 2010 7:50 AM PST
i have heros of the forgotten kingdoms, and players handbook 2 and am working on rolling a sentinal but i have one huge question do they get 1 at will or 3 at wills
Flag furious_kender November 15, 2010 7:52 AM PST

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:50AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

i have heros of the forgotten kingdoms, and players handbook 2 and am working on rolling a sentinal but i have one huge question do they get 1 at will or 3 at wills




They get 1 at-will and their animal companion has the at-will Animal Attack. 

Flag undergroundplayer November 15, 2010 8:05 AM PST

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:52AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:50AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

i have heros of the forgotten kingdoms, and players handbook 2 and am working on rolling a sentinal but i have one huge question do they get 1 at will or 3 at wills




They get 1 at-will and their animal companion has the at-will Animal Attack. 


ok now part 2 for this chill wind vs tending strike? im going for leader as a secondary role as a drow spring sentinal

Flag yesnomu November 15, 2010 11:37 AM PST

Nov 15, 2010 -- 8:05AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:52AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:50AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

i have heros of the forgotten kingdoms, and players handbook 2 and am working on rolling a sentinal but i have one huge question do they get 1 at will or 3 at wills




They get 1 at-will and their animal companion has the at-will Animal Attack. 


ok now part 2 for this chill wind vs tending strike? im going for leader as a secondary role as a drow spring sentinal



If you're a controller first, then the controlling at-will seems like the better option. Tending Strike is the THP one, right?

Flag furious_kender November 15, 2010 12:03 PM PST

Nov 15, 2010 -- 8:05AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:52AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:50AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

i have heros of the forgotten kingdoms, and players handbook 2 and am working on rolling a sentinal but i have one huge question do they get 1 at will or 3 at wills




They get 1 at-will and their animal companion has the at-will Animal Attack. 


ok now part 2 for this chill wind vs tending strike? im going for leader as a secondary role as a drow spring sentinal




I would go Gasping Tide or Firehawk personally. 

Flag undergroundplayer November 15, 2010 1:03 PM PST

Nov 15, 2010 -- 12:03PM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 8:05AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:52AM, furious_kender wrote:

Nov 15, 2010 -- 7:50AM, undergroundplayer wrote:

i have heros of the forgotten kingdoms, and players handbook 2 and am working on rolling a sentinal but i have one huge question do they get 1 at will or 3 at wills




They get 1 at-will and their animal companion has the at-will Animal Attack. 


ok now part 2 for this chill wind vs tending strike? im going for leader as a secondary role as a drow spring sentinal




I would go Gasping Tide or Firehawk personally. 


Tending strike is the thp one yes
what books are grasping tide and firehawk in?

Flag Lord_Ventnor November 15, 2010 1:46 PM PST
Fire Hawk is in Primal Power, while Grasping Tide can be found in the Player's Handbook Heroes series of miniatures.
Flag jedbob June 26, 2011 7:01 PM PDT
Am I missing something with Sentinels? None of their powers explicitly have the "implement" keyword, and as such doesn't that mean that they don't get any implement bonuses? Although my Sentinel wields a spear in her main hand and a magical totem (+3) in her off hand, Character Builder, at least, is not including any bonuses to hit or damage. AFAIK, The only keywords in Sentinel powers that show up with any regularity are "primal" and "weapon". Why be able to use implements if they're not going to have any real benefit?
Flag furious_kender June 26, 2011 7:45 PM PDT

Jun 26, 2011 -- 7:01PM, jedbob wrote:

Am I missing something with Sentinels? None of their powers explicitly have the "implement" keyword, and as such doesn't that mean that they don't get any implement bonuses? Although my Sentinel wields a spear in her main hand and a magical totem (+3) in her off hand, Character Builder, at least, is not including any bonuses to hit or damage. AFAIK, The only keywords in Sentinel powers that show up with any regularity are "primal" and "weapon". Why be able to use implements if they're not going to have any real benefit?




Just an FYI, Alien is keeping the up to date version of the guide.  I stopped updating this one very shortly after creation because of his guide.

To answer your question, sentinels can pick druid powers and can use any druid power that doesn't have the Beast keyword.  Thus, implement prof is important, even if the essentials books don't list the sentinel as having any implement powers per se. 

The CB correctly isn't adding implement effects to weapon powers or vice versa. 

Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.
Jump Menu:
 
    Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
    No registered users viewing