Community

Enemies don't even need to spontaneously attack your summons. Due to its low defense and HP issue, a few AOE/multiattacks with some aura could easily make it disappear.

And yes, 1 or 2 turns stun is soooo better in a party where the striker and leader could finish things off fast and clean. If there is only 1 or 2 opponent in the group have the ability to inflict massive damage or notorious effects, then one summon might be enough. But once that number rises to 3 or more, which happens so often after paragon, it would not be suffice at all to have 1 merely grabbed or prone, because they could still do what they are intended to do: handing out horrifying conditions that paralyse your whole party.

As I said, if you go front line, you would be an easy target for the enemies if their initial intention is you (which does not make a difference anyway) due to your low defense or someone else in the front line, around whom they would have already clustered (which again would not make any difference).

I have said that my hard control is not as solid as other controllers, my point is that their are other ways to control just putting an extra body out on the field can help with control. I am defending the fact that summons can be a powerful tool for controler, not only via their effects but by putting another body on the field and giving you an action advantage over you enemies by effectively giving you more action a turn.

As for their possibly being better options there may be but this is a summoner build and has focused on that aspect. The other aspect is that my summons attacks are more accurate so their effects are more likely to take effect (+3/+5 to hit over other powers).  

As for the polearm momentum build I do have a build that uses that option, but generally I find it bad in the current enviroment with all the item rules changing going on as it is highly item dependent build. Though I am working on a none item dependent version, but it currently has some MAD issues I am trying to iron out.

I do understand their are some other option out there that can be really powerful but that is not the point of this build, and I think that the summons in a real game can be really powerful tools for a variaty of reasons. I believe this build is an excellent addition to any party and can really help out as a controller in a variaty of ways. It is a bit harder to measure then some other builds that is true but having played summoners in pretty much every edition including 4e I have found them to be highly verstile tools in any spell casters bag of tricks.

On another note: I am in the process of updating the build utilizing some wild shape powers which provide better control effects. This will reduce the builds Ranged capabilities but enhance its overall control aspects.

Edit: As to primal storm it is not action free, while yes it can be sustained (minor action), and has an effect that is useable each round (OA action). Meanwhile summons are action free when using instinctive actions. So while similar the Summons come out on top as far as action advantage go.

@ppaladin123

The build actually doesn't direct its summons that often the idea is to get an action advantage by using the instinctive action of you summons to have them do their own thing while you do yours. This is effectively giving you an extra standard action each round with some soft to hard control attached as using your abilities you are able to easily position the summons where they can do the most damage.

I have actually talked about the summons as a DPR tool with the concept of focus fire (aka multiple attacks against a single target or multiple targets). As for what I can do with my minor action that is actually quite a bit, by level 30 I can use it to shift, or power many of my utilities. second wind to heal, if need be command my summons, etc. There is alot you can do with minors besides wild shaping and so long as primal storm is active it is harder to do those things.

As for Writhing Henge I actually missed that summon power and will be adding it to the build as another summon with a control option though I think that I will drop the guardian briar for it as the crocodile is still a powerful control tool in all tiers of play, via the combo of oak skewer/windstorm, and then isolated grab to keep the target out of combat range for multiple turns.

I am not trying to be a pain or sound stuborn, I am just trying to explain that I believe summons can be a nice control tool, and can bring alot to the table as the issue of their effectiveness was raised. I have said that by the numbers their hard control is less, but they have other things going for them, and the point of this build is to capatilize on those things along with what control they bring.

To summarize the things that make the summons a nice tool, are action advantage, consistent encounter long ability, high accuracy, putting an extra body on the field (aka numbers advantage), ability to focus fire for strong DPR and stacking soft control, abilty if need be spread fire for multi target hinderance, and a few other things that are hard to quantify in a non play enviroment.

Anyways thanks for the find of Writhing Hedge it is a really nice tool in this builds bag of tricks.

On another note after playing around with it I actually don't think I will be using the wild shape stuff for this build. I find that that ability to mix things up at range and in melee that the current version has is an invaluable tool in actual play.

I disagree I have stated my point as to what the build does, where its weakness lie (straight hard control), and where its strengths lie (durability, action advantage, numbers advantage, Stacking Soft Control). I will admit that it is different kinda controller and that it is not for everyone but in many situation and in many games this build is an excellent party addition.

For example take a party with mostly ranged combatants, the builds ability to put out a melee summon and go into melee itself can go along way to establishing a front line for the party. Leaving the other party members free to do their thing, and since the build can throw ranged itself while in melee it can actually help with the focus fire of the rest of the party. Meanwhile it is putting down some nice soft control (Possibly multiple forms of soft control) to further enhance the parties tactics and hinder the enemies.

As for not taking other things into consideration I believe I have addressed what other controllers do multiple times. From other druid powers to other controllers abilties and compared where I think the druid come up lacking and where it shines. 

My point is that the builds overall abitlies when combined together, Summons, Encounters, Feats, Defense, etc add up to something that is actually quite effective, and while the individual parts may be weaker then some other things out their total package is quite strong. The idea here is synergy of abilities creatiing a whole that is greater then the individual parts.

At this point there is nothing more I can say on the subject. If you don't like it don't play it but from my testing having played summoners, and having played more traditional controllers I find that they are comparable in an actual game enviroment with optmized party members. They bring different things to the table sure, but then every PC brings something different.