Community

Here's my comments on the powers. I'll be using your list as a base and then pointing out differing opinions etc.

The At-Will list is perfect. No changes there.

The level 1 encounter power list should feature a change: Two-Fanged Strike should be a blue power, as it has tremendous damage potential, and doesn't have Fox Cunning's drawback, which is having to get hit to activate it. In my opinion, how useful they are is inversely proportional, and depends on your attack bonus. The higher it is, the better Two-Fanged gets and the worse Cunning becomes. Thus, it is as good a choice as Cunning (Or better, with the appropriate setup. For example, a melee ranger with a high to-hit chance using PA.)

The dailies are A-okay.

The utilities should be revised. Crucial advice is good, but it ain't all it's cracked up to be, as rangers don't have that much overlap with other classes. That said, it should still be black, as a success in perception, endurance, or Athletics can be very vital.

Unbalancing parry is red crap. The benefit it grants is rather minor and can be easily obtained with clever positioning.

Yield Ground, meanwhile, is either blue or sky blue. It's a given that you're going to be hit sometime and Yield Ground is both an offensive tool, repositioning you and giving you a chance to strike at the right foe, and a defensive tool, boosting ALL of your defenses after just one hit (For comparison, Combat Anticipation boosts only by one, is a paragon feat, and doesn't work against every attack). It stays useful throughout your career, and can save you a lot of pain.

The encounter 3 powers should be reevaluated. True, free attacks are good, and Disruptive strike is awesome for it's penalty, but it would be foolish to underestimate cut and run and thundertusk boar strike. The first one is basically a retributionless strike, which comes in really hand for meleers, and the second one, while requiring two hits for the full effect, comes in pretty handy for ranged attackers, who can use it to get out of a sticky situation, even with a one square push. Shadow Wasp Strike sucks, though.

The level 5 powers are okay. Maybe I'd emphasize how Frenzied Skirmish likely means a lost turn for a foe with no save, but it's okay.

No comment on level 6. I agree with it.

On level 7, no comments. It's basically a lowpoint for the ranger.

I agree on level 9, too. It would really take a special kind of moron not to take Attacks on the run, as it does ludicrous damage.

On level 10, the only change I'd make is stress how useful Expeditious Stride is. It either makes you fly through the battlefield, or it means you can play Kobold for a while. And we all know those sneaky buggers have an awesome power.

No comment on level 13. It's a succinct and good analysis of the level.

Same with 15.

No comment on 16, too.

However, that streak of agreements ends on level 17. While I agree Cheetah's rake is awesome, I find it really weird that you do not recommend Triple Shot. Free attack or not, Arrow of Vengeance pales in comparison to a power that inflicts such gross damage (A pit fighter archer could easily add 40-50 damage on multiple constant bonuses, before we even factor W damage). True, it requires a setup, but I'm sure the Tactical warlord will be happy to oblige and give you a Warlord's Favor if it means such a huge amount of damage.

I agree once again on level 19. Maybe I'd stress how powerful Cruel Cage of Steel can be (For example, a Pit Fighter Lasting Frost ranger can deal upwards of 55 extra damage, and the attacks are extra likely to hit, AND they have debuffs), but that's it.

We think alike for level 22. In my opinion, Forest Ghost and Safe Stride are the better powers of the bunch, but they're all pretty good.

Level 23 is a no-brainer in the power choice. There's nothing I can add.

I have to disagree on level 25, though. For a melee ranger, Tiger's Reflex IS A TRAP. It's not that it is a bad power, buuuuuuuut...it overlaps with Follow-Up blow, so you can't have them both. Thus, Bloodstorm is the choice to take with a melee ranger if you just HAVE to pick something of this level.

On level 27, I've nuthin' to say.

On level 29, though, my opinion is this: a melee ranger shouldn't replace his Attacks on the run until this level, and here swap it for Follow-up Blow. If your fellow party members do their job, your hit rate should be anywhere from 60% to 85% consistently. Thus, the Blow can be very, very deadly.

Other than that, there's nothing else to say. This is a pretty good job, and I applaud you for the analysis.

I'm disappointed that Manticore-whatever (Encounter 23) was omitted. You get damage that approaches the levels of Three-in-one shot (Daily 29), and you get to use it every encounter.