Community

I'm new to Magic Online, so I can't comment on the differences that much, but the first thing I noticed after I'd installed it, being very vulnarable to RSI, that there are almost no keyboard shortcuts. It's all clicking and dragging.

Except for the Function keys when playing, to skip over some of the phases, there's not much there (or at least I couldn't find any on the web, if there are, please let me know!). I'd like to navigate through my cards and selecting them for my deck using just my keyboard, that would make life so much easier. 

I really changed my computer habits after I realised using my mouse all the time was giving me serious pain in my arm, hand and neck. I found out that, although it takes some getting used to, using your keyboard is actually a lot faster in most applications (at work I mostly use Excel). I understand that the interface should be understandable for new players because there's a lot going on, but using keyboard shortcuts doesn't take that away at all, it just sits on top of everything.

I'm sure a lot of users (even the ones that don't care using a mouse from a health-perspective) would like to invest some time in learning keyboard combinations to be faster at navigating / deckbuilding and playing.

And while I'm at it, it would be best if you could customize it yourself =) I understand there are still no plans for a Mac version so I finally committed to installing Windows on my Mac, but the Mac can only use the Function keys in combination with another key (Fn). What's wrong with using "Enter" or your "Space Bar" to skip through phase and action alerts? Selecting the answer yes or no with your arrow keys? Why F2? I feel like I'm back to the 80's using Function keys to navigate through my MSDOS programs...

So if you could examine what possibilities are there, you would make a lot of users happy! 

I do not understand why you guys are not taking a scan version of the cards, just like other TCG online games? Instead you try to recreate the cards and they look so bad.. I would love to look at my collection and see the real cards, not bugged designed cards..

I really don't understand the opposition to a "binder view" of one's collection. It may be that the new view is more intuitive for building decks, but it's definitely not intuitive. Nor is it, to use a Maro word, "grokkable." It seems like something that makes sense to the people developing the UI.

But as I'm sure you're aware, what makes sense to a software developer doesn't necessarily make sense to the end user. If I'm playing a card game, a binder of cards makes sense to me -- it looks like the sort of thing I would have. But a bunch of individual pictures doesn't have that kind of mental image for me.

I may be the only one, but I also really miss the tables view that v2(.5? I think that's what it was) had. That felt very nice for casual play -- it meant envisioning sitting down and playing a card game with someone, and it was evocative. Now there are no options but lists.  There are some skins and I like what they look like much better than V3 and even V2, but they don't make me feel like I'm hanging out. That's okay if I'm in tournament mode, I guess, but when I want fun? Lists aren't fun. (Sorry, I'm not Azorius.)

I know there were early concept screens of the table view, so I know it was planned for and scrapped. I doubt it will come back, so I'm not trying to beat a dead horse. Except that I kind of am, but it's not about needing tables -- it's about missing flavor, and wanting it back. I play casually on MTGO far less than I did in the days of V2. Part of that's a shift in my preferences, but part of it is that when I fire up a program full of nothing but lists of games, cards, and statistics -- well, it's not a place to just show up and hang, it's a place to do something. So I end up in TP testing, or in tournaments.

Which is all fine -- I wouldn't play in tournaments if I disliked it. But I think the game's ambiance is part of why I don't just fire it up because I feel like playing Magic.

It feels like the people developing this game are thinking about all the math and presenting something that feels -- mathy, nerdy, "for the intelligent only"-ey. "This is for geeks!" is totally fine, and I'm not dissing math or meaning to belittle all the work you've clearly done and are clearly intending to do. But even geeks who love buttons, I think, begin to notice when there's no flavor.

And, well, while I'm a competitive player and all, a big part of Magic is the flavor.

Stop giving us the lists you're proud to make work right and expecting us to squee.

Give us something where we feel like we're basking in Magic, not drowning in buttons and modes and toggles, and I think you'll see much more positive responses.

Dec 20, 2012 -- 4:00AM, WBurgess wrote:

I'll only comment on 2 areas, I have have given alot of feedback elsewhere (forums, feedback form, survey etc)

Collection screen.

I get that this is a little better for building decks etc, but this is mean to be a collectible card game. I can't be alone in that I often look through the collection screen, looking through cards I own, set by set getting ideas for decks etc. The new collection screen basically makes this impossible, all your cards are just lumped there in one big pile, no separation, just a big list to scroll through. I don't feel like I own a MTG card collection online anymore.

I agree totally and no you are not the only one looking through your collection.  I look at my collection because I like to see what I have won.  It brings a feeling of acomplishment because I am primarily a limited player and roughly half (probably less) of the cards in my collection I have gained by prize payouts in limited events.  I like it when I am flipping pages and I see that foil mythic and remember the game that I won the 8 man queue with it.  Or the time I opened six rares in 4 pack sealed pool and completely dominated.  You can't just flip pages to appreciate the cards we own.  Now you have to build a deck to appreciate them.