Community

Nov 12, 2012 -- 3:36PM, alan2here wrote:

Guildpact Returns

Enchantment
All permanents have protection from permanents that don't share a color with them.

not sure if this works as worded, but fine.
White is allowed protection from stuff, and blue is allowed protection from weird stuff.

 
If no combat occurred this turn, all players gain 2 life.

No. Lifegain is not blue and does not belong on a card that can be cast with only blue mana.

 
Detain all colorless permanents.

If you play this on your second main phase, this is akin to a time walk against a lot of decks.
Wow, I'm brainfarting today.
Anywho, this doesn't work as written, it needs to be timed somehow.
"When this enters the battlefield"
 "When you cast"
"At the beginning of your upkeep"

I would add something on, like "if there has been no combat stage for the last five turn, sacrifise ~

Nov 12, 2012 -- 4:12PM, Kingreaper wrote:

Nov 12, 2012 -- 3:36PM, alan2here wrote:

Detain all colorless permanents.

I'm guessing you're forgetting that lands are colourless permanents?

Most lands are. /asininity

I'm undecided on something like "If no combat has occurred for the last five turns, sacrifise ~.". I'd include some means of counting, such as counters.


It seems blue and well as a white, or at least very much not red, green or black, so it shouldn't be as splashable in those colors. It also need not require use of a blue mana, as it would if it were .

I originally had it being but you said a card that can be cast with just blue shouldn't have lifegain, although I should think some colorless cards that therefore can be cast with all blue include lifegain.

Another alternative is , however I like .