Community

Oct 30, 2012 -- 9:48PM, Hhooven4 wrote:

I dislike mass land removal, it earns massive frown tech from my group.  Whether it is in the form of land conversion, as mentioned previously, or outright destruction it is the only thing that I think I truly hate in Commander.  I also think that cards that let you take extra turns should be banned (even though I have posted an X Turns in a Row deck) as I think it functionally removes players from the game in the same way as land removal.

Extra turns can be dealt with if all players agree to a limit on the number of turns in a row of 2, 3, or 4.

Oct 30, 2012 -- 11:38PM, Rpetiger wrote:

A Green or black deck would be screwed with no way out.

Splinter

Molder Slug

Tribute to the Wild

I admit, none of these are GREAT answers but at least green gets SOMETHING.....poor black.

Oct 31, 2012 -- 3:21PM, Disturbed185 wrote:

I think you should play whatever you want to, in your commander deck. I'd stay clear of the banlist. But beyond that play what you want. The important thing is actually to match the decks in your area. If the folks you play with play just for kicks...then play just for kicks. If your group likes enormous plays and huge board swings: Resulting in the biggest most obscene plays do it.

Whenever something impressive happens, that's when magic memories are made.

I severely disagree with this attitude about being a care bear while playing Commander. I think the real problem is timing. Learn the timing of when to play the powerful cards. Don't play them at an early stage to shut the rest of the group down. Every deck has a weakness, pack plenty of answers and quit qq'ing.

Thank you!