Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
No registered users viewing
|
Jump Menu:
Show More
This program will guide you through sorting the cards in Return to Ravnica. Just click the card you believe to be generally stronger. When you are done you will get a copyable list of the sorted cards with associated grades which you can then use in rating threads. This is only for people with patience and some spare time though, as it will probably take around a thousand clicks to get through, and that's a lot of decisions to make, even if they are just decisions between two cards. 
Are we rating this for limited or constructed or does it matter?
These are the limited forums, aren't they? Anyway, this is for you, not me. Your results aren't pooled into some database somewhere or anything like that, it just gives you a personal list to use however you want. You could sort everything based on constructed power level if you were interested in that, it wouldn't hurt anything. 
If you want what it gave me as feedback, not sure it's exactly on-target but I guess it's a good rule of thumb:
Spoiler: Show A Isperia, Supreme Judge Armada Wurm Sphinx's Revelation Jace, Architect of Thought Trostani, Selesnya's Voice Angel of Serenity Mizzium Mortars Desecration Demon Collective Blessing Deadbridge Goliath Rakdos's Return Niv-Mizzet, Dracogenius Cyclonic Rift A- Archon of the Triumvirate Rakdos, Lord of Riots Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord Supreme Verdict Martial Law Hellhole Flailer Mercurial Chemister Chaos Imps Vraska the Unseen Vitu-Ghazi Guildmage New Prahv Guildmage Korozda Guildmage Detention Sphere Corpsejack Menace B+ Hypersonic Dragon Righteous Authority Palisade Giant Sphinx of the Chimes Abrupt Decay Necropolis Regent Loxodon Smiter Underworld Connections Dreadbore Pack Rat Rix Maadi Guildmage Carnival Hellsteed Wayfaring Temple Overgrown Tomb Rakdos Ragemutt Arrest Bloodfray Giant Ultimate Price Grove of the Guardian Izzet Charm B Soulsworn Spirit Thoughtflare Stab Wound Lyev Skyknight Phantom General Lotleth Troll Growing Ranks Selesnya Charm Dead Reveler Thrill-Kill Assassin Civic Saber Skymark Roc Izzet Staticaster Steam Vents Splatter Thug Azorius Justiciar Temple Garden Annihilating Fire Hallowed Fountain Slime Molding B- Street Spasm Chromatic Lantern Call of the Conclave Hussar Patrol Common Bond Dreg Mangler Explosive Impact Blustersquall Gore-House Chainwalker Keening Apparition Rites of Reaping Blood Crypt Avenging Arrow Rootborn Defenses Auger Spree Wild Beastmaster Sluiceway Scorpion Eyes in the Skies Nivix Guildmage Golgari Keyrune C+ Rakdos Cackler Dryad Militant Knightly Valor Ash Zealot Deathrite Shaman Judge's Familiar Golgari Charm Rakdos Keyrune Centaur's Herald Golgari Decoy Jarad's Orders Grim Roustabout Transguild Promenade Centaur Healer Daggerdrome Imp Azor's Elocutors Rogue's Passage Tavern Swindler Frostburn Weird Coursers' Accord Sewer Shambler Goblin Electromancer Perilous Shadow Voidwielder Azorius Keyrune Azorius Charm Azorius Arrester C Security Blockade Stonefare Crocodile Runewing Launch Party Korozda Monitor Grave Betrayal Guttersnipe Skyline Predator Druid's Deliverance Syncopate Assassin's Strike Faerie Impostor Lobber Crew Tenement Crasher Street Sweeper Fencing Ace Savage Surge Death's Presence Inaction Injunction Cobblebrute Essence Backlash Stealer of Secrets Towering Indrik Paralyzing Grasp Utvara Hellkite Trostani's Judgment Rubbleback Rhino C- Axebane Guardian Tower Drake Gatecreeper Vine Slum Reaper Brushstrider Electrickery Soul Tithe Pursuit of Flight Precinct Captain Rakdos Guildgate Gobbling Ooze Hover Barrier Pyroconvergence Spawn of Rix Maadi Zanikev Locust Trestle Troll Drudge Beetle Giant Growth Rakdos Ringleader Inspiration Selesnya Guildgate Volatile Rig Crosstown Courier Izzet Guildgate Traitorous Instinct Dramatic Rescue Sunspire Griffin Azorius Guildgate Swift Justice D+ Risen Sanctuary Cremate Slitherhead Vassal Soul Cancel Selesnya Sentry Seller of Songbirds Golgari Guildgate Rakdos Shred-Freak Selesnya Keyrune Dynacharge Concordia Pegasus Ogre Jailbreaker Doorkeeper Horncaller's Chant Mind Rot Goblin Rally Treasured Find D Sphere of Safety Teleportal Viashino Racketeer Golgari Longlegs Izzet Keyrune Ethereal Armor Archweaver Armory Guard Sundering Growth Skull Rend Deviant Glee Mana Bloom Chemister's Trick Cryptborn Horror Isperia's Skywatch Grisly Salvage Minotaur Aggressor Aerial Predation Chorus of Might Mizzium Skin D- Terrus Wurm Aquus Steed Dark Revenant Seek the Horizon Slaughter Games Fall of the Gavel Dispel Rakdos Charm Counterflux Guild Feud Codex Shredder Downsize Pithing Needle Blistercoil Weird Rest in Peace Bazaar Krovod Batterhorn Worldspine Wurm Nivmagus Elemental Havoc Festival F Vandalblast Axebane Stag Catacomb Slug Conjured Currency Firemind's Foresight Trained Caracal Chronic Flooding Drainpipe Vermin Psychic Spiral Oak Street Innkeeper Survey the Wreckage Shrieking Affliction Epic Experiment Racecourse Fury Heroes' Reunion Destroy the Evidence Bellows Lizard Urban Burgeoning Tablet of the Guilds Search Warrant Search the City If anyone has any questions as to some of these evaluations, hit me! 
Some objections:
sphinx's revelation: Blue sun's zenith wasn't A+ good. trostani: Awkward to cast, doesn't read "You win the game" unless you have a centaur or knight token. corpsejack menace: A lot of the time this will just be a rhox brute hellhole flailer: it's good, but not THAT good. Not bomb-level good, in that it alone wins you games. jarad: awkward to cast, not that huge except lategame, doesn't win that quickly or consistently. downsize: can be a nice combat trick, save your dudes from a trade and save you some life. codex shredder: if you're playing a slow control deck, I think you want this. dark revenant: 2/2 flier for 2 that can trade off with their 2/2s and ensure that your next topdeck isn't a land. terrus wurm: surprisingly good. It's a lategame fatty, and it makes another lategame fatty. axebane stag: Given the lack of good removal, this is sometimes actually something you're happy MDing bellows lizard: It's like somberwald vigilante in AVR: sometimes you're playing the super-aggro deck that wants a 1 drop, even if it's mediocre. psychic spiral: cast it for like 5-10 and you're probably winning that game, since your draws are more likely to be good and you have inevitability. teleportal: Sometimes you just cast this on a clogged board and win. Like downsize, it would be better in different colors, but you can always splash it off a guildgate or 2. This format has boardstalls quite a bit. grisly salvage: this is impulse + bin a scavenge dude. How is this bad? viashino racketeer: it's OK for curve filler in rakdos. golgari longlegs: this is solid. It can be a curve topper in rakdos and sometimes just be the biggest thing on the board, or it can just stop your opponent from attacking. With so little removal, sometimes fat just wins you games. risen sanctuary: clogged boards + little removal = fat being good. selesnya keyrune: It's mana ramp, or it's a body. And unlike the izzet one, it's actually a pretty solid one. concordia pegasus: swings in clogged boards or blocks 2 power dudes. Not spectacular, but not bad... gobbling ooze: bloodflow connisseur from AVR ate butcher ghouls. This guys has no easily renewable food supply. axebane guardian: manafixing, ramping, and blocks their 2 power dude. This guy is GREAT. giant growth: this is awesome. It is a 1 cmc combat trick that will lead to your guy winning the fight 90% of the time. rakdos ringleader: I don't think I'd ever want this guy as my 6 drop. He's just 3 power. Kinda underwhelming.
My results. Made a couple misclicks and didn't think too hard on anything. I was kinda going back and forth between sorting and doing other things. Spoiler: Show A
Vraska the Unseen Mizzium Mortars Jace, Architect of Thought Armada Wurm Pack Rat Deadbridge Goliath Niv-Mizzet, Dracogenius Mercurial Chemister Isperia, Supreme Judge Martial Law Supreme Verdict Hypersonic Dragon Rakdos's Return A- Sphinx's Revelation Desecration Demon Underworld Connections Cyclonic Rift Collective Blessing Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord Angel of Serenity Loxodon Smiter Vitu-Ghazi Guildmage Arrest Bloodfray Giant Hellhole Flailer Lotleth Troll Rakdos, Lord of Riots B+ Archon of the Triumvirate Chaos Imps Sphinx of the Chimes Detention Sphere Street Spasm Auger Spree Ultimate Price Skymark Roc Azorius Charm Corpsejack Menace Carnival Hellsteed Necropolis Regent Stab Wound Dreg Mangler Thoughtflare Korozda Guildmage Call of the Conclave Centaur Healer Thrill-Kill Assassin Splatter Thug B Gore-House Chainwalker Annihilating Fire Nivix Guildmage Wayfaring Temple Civic Saber Wild Beastmaster Rites of Reaping Growing Ranks Izzet Charm Coursers' Accord Rakdos Ragemutt Sluiceway Scorpion Azorius Keyrune Golgari Keyrune Selesnya Keyrune Rakdos Keyrune Abrupt Decay Rix Maadi Guildmage Dreadbore Selesnya Charm B- Lyev Skyknight Grove of the Guardian Izzet Keyrune Deathrite Shaman Explosive Impact Izzet Staticaster Assassin's Strike Teleportal Righteous Authority Precinct Captain Trostani's Judgment Trostani, Selesnya's Voice New Prahv Guildmage Slime Molding Savage Surge Giant Growth Inaction Injunction Frostburn Weird Dead Reveler Transguild Promenade C+ Overgrown Tomb Steam Vents Centaur's Herald Trestle Troll Blood Crypt Ash Zealot Jarad's Orders Perilous Shadow Eyes in the Skies Runewing Zanikev Locust Rakdos Cackler Grim Roustabout Temple Garden Golgari Guildgate Selesnya Guildgate Izzet Guildgate Dramatic Rescue Common Bond Palisade Giant Spawn of Rix Maadi Chromatic Lantern Hussar Patrol Sunspire Griffin Skyline Predator Hover Barrier Voidwielder C Hallowed Fountain Rakdos Guildgate Azorius Guildgate Drudge Beetle Soulsworn Spirit Grisly Salvage Stonefare Crocodile Gatecreeper Vine Lobber Crew Brushstrider Korozda Monitor Azorius Justiciar Launch Party Stealer of Secrets Golgari Decoy Axebane Guardian Rakdos Shred-Freak Slum Reaper Goblin Rally Keening Apparition Paralyzing Grasp Azorius Arrester Dryad Militant Risen Sanctuary Isperia's Skywatch Swift Justice Grave Betrayal C- Selesnya Sentry Rootborn Defenses Soul Tithe Rogue's Passage Guttersnipe Treasured Find Azor's Elocutors Death's Presence Volatile Rig Faerie Impostor Dark Revenant Vassal Soul Avenging Arrow Utvara Hellkite Rubbleback Rhino Inspiration Golgari Charm Goblin Electromancer Towering Indrik Tower Drake Traitorous Instinct Golgari Longlegs Syncopate Pithing Needle Cobblebrute Terrus Wurm Fencing Ace Knightly Valor Sewer Shambler D+ Tenement Crasher Chemister's Trick Seller of Songbirds Doorkeeper Daggerdrome Imp Security Blockade Electrickery Blustersquall Tavern Swindler Ogre Jailbreaker Druid's Deliverance Pyroconvergence Cryptborn Horror Sundering Growth Essence Backlash Crosstown Courier Conjured Currency Skull Rend D Mind Rot Concordia Pegasus Archweaver Downsize Bazaar Krovod Dynacharge Nivmagus Elemental Slitherhead Viashino Racketeer Mana Bloom Codex Shredder Ethereal Armor Guild Feud Deviant Glee Horncaller's Chant Dispel Minotaur Aggressor Seek the Horizon Worldspine Wurm Psychic Spiral D- Gobbling Ooze Phantom General Axebane Stag Batterhorn Catacomb Slug Street Sweeper Bellows Lizard Chorus of Might Cancel Aerial Predation Armory Guard Rakdos Ringleader Heroes' Reunion Mizzium Skin Aquus Steed Pursuit of Flight Fall of the Gavel Havoc Festival Cremate Epic Experiment F Survey the Wreckage Trained Caracal Rakdos Charm Judge's Familiar Drainpipe Vermin Counterflux Firemind's Foresight Search Warrant Racecourse Fury Oak Street Innkeeper Shrieking Affliction Sphere of Safety Chronic Flooding Rest in Peace Tablet of the Guilds Vandalblast Blistercoil Weird Slaughter Games Destroy the Evidence Urban Burgeoning Search the City
|
