Community

I need advice or deck suggestions for a deck centered around Splinterfright , I love that guy.

So i've only been playing Magic for about 6 months and have just recently begun to attend my local game shop's FNM. I started playing theg Grave Power intro pack when I first started and i've been playing a modified version of it ever since. Splinterfright idealizes what I want this deck to do, grow more powefull even as my creatures die. Till now i've been playing the deck U/G for some power creature mill but with RTR i'm wondering if B/G would be more appropriate? What deck do you guys think Splinterfright would work best in?

Here is my current deck:

Lands (20 x ):
10 x Forest
7 x Island
3 x Evolving Wild

Creatures (29 x ):
4 x Dawntreader Elk
4 x Boneyard Wurm
4 x Splinterfright
4 x Archaeomancer
2 x Stern Mentor
4 x Ghoultree

Instants/Sorceries (11 x )
4 x Tracker's Instinct
3 x Gnaw to the Bone
4 x Sleep


Should I keep the deck U/G heading into RTR just adding some new graveyard flavour G cards or should I kick out the blue for all the new Golgari cards. I love how fast the blue mills though and i'm worried that U/b won't be able to mill fast enough.

What are your thoughts?

Additionally, this is my advice for improving the deck

Mulch is fantastic for this deck, it helps you hit your land drops and mills you at the same time
Jace, Memory Adept is a milling machine and a win condition in himself
Spider Spawning , Laboratory Maniac , Kessig Cagebreakers and Psychic Spiral are all win conditions
Armored Skaab gives you a blocker and mills you
Forbidden Alchemy helps you filter your decks while not letting the cards you want get away
Snapcaster Mage makes use of spells in your graveyard
Thought Scour draws you and mills you


As for what you have, Archeomancer is slow, I am not a fan personally while Sleep and Gnaw to the bone are not great (well, sleep is cool but not necessary for this deck)

As far as blue green goes, I've done quite well in FNM with it.

I have 4 ghoultrees, 4 splinterfrights, 2 boneyard wurms (not a fan)

Boneyards aren't REALLY a turn 2 drop, they are more like a turn 3-4 drop, which by that time you can get a ghoultree out.

Get 4 Armored Skaab . 1/4 creature, mills 4, only costs 3? I also run 4 Deranged Alchemist and 2 Ruinator Skkaab just in case I need a clutch monster.

Also don't forget Artful Dodge . 2 turn win with a ghoultree out. So far, it has been extremely consistent. Not really a "luck deck" when everything I play are creatures (for their utility) and spells with flashback. Which means I don't run Mulch since nothing in the deck is above 3 mana anyway (besides ghoultree). 

There is also Gavin Verhey's list from last week, though he was bound by the fact that he couldnt use RTR cards that hadnt been officially spoiled

4 x Arbor Elf
4 x Boneyard Wurm
1 x Disciple of Bolas
4 x Dreg Mangler
2 x Ghoultree
2 x Gravecrawler
2 x Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord
1 x Kessig Cagebreakers
2 x Korozda Guildmage
4 x Splinterfright
1 x Tree of Redemption

4 x Grisly Salvage
3 x Jarad's Orders
4 x Mulch

9 x Forest
1 x Grim Backwoods
4 x Overgrown Tomb
4 x Swamp
4 x Woodland Cemetery 
 

I know it lacks blue but I thought it offered a nice insight

Thanks for the great responses guys! It does seem as nopemx6 mentioned that the choice between blue and black is a choice between faster mill or more win conditions. 

@Cogminded Mulch is an amazing card and i've always been on the fence about including it. Many of the cards you recomended are certainly great for the mill aspect of the deck. I think I may try something more like Gavin Verhey's list that you posted. Looks interesting.

@supafongboon I completely agree about the Boneyard Wurm . They're a nice card but certainly not a T2 drop. The */* is nice once you have a lot of creatures milled but thats not going to happen till turn 4 or so. Splinterfright of course has his own milling built in so its not nearly as dependant on others cards.

@mogg_flinger_ I really like the deck you put together. Specifically the new golgaric cards that really do fit into this deck style really well. Deathrite Shaman , Dreg Mangler and of course Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord are all amazing and will definitely have a great place in the deck. I see how with a lot of land fetch just having one or two island could work in a tricolor deck, just a splash I guess. But I wonder if its worth it for just the Tracker's instinct.

@Jman22 That is a great deck. Looks a bit expensive though and I don't understand the Avacyn's Pilgrim . The Deadbridge Goliath is particularly attractive since it would be part of the mana curve that i'm lacking at the moment.

Okay I think I have a good grasp on the cards I want to keep from my U/G mill deck and which cards I want to put in from the different colors:

Keeepers:
4x Dawntreader Elk (A good two drop that fetchs land, has always been a solid card in the past)
2x-4x Boneyard Wurm (there are better 2 drops then the wurm though he has nice syngery with B/G sacrifice effects)
4x Splinterfright (He's the star of the show!)
4x Ghoultree (Good top deck and nice mid-game to boot)
4x Mulch (an excellent 2 drop that mills and fetchs land, i've used these before but looks like i'll include them again)

Black Cards that Fit:
Deathrite Shaman (While he's just another creature card in the graveyard on the battle field he can both mana ramp AND alter the life balance)
Korozda Guildmage (Both abilites are great just a little mana intensive, A great card but not the best 2 drop in the deck, still a nice ard)
Dreg Mangler (3/3 with haste for 3 is great especially if you factor in his extra usefullness in the grave, though his scavenge wouldn't be huge)
Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord (An amazing card period. I will definitely use him if I can find or buy him.)
Deadbridge Goliath (I really like this card for some reason, 5/5 for 4 is great but even more I find that his scavenge could be usefull late game)
Abrupt Decay I've never really run a lot of removal but I like the cut of this card's jib, might be best for a sideboard though
Grisly Salvage Another card that made me say, wow. Its basically the best of both worlds between Tracker's Instinct and mulch. Autoinclude
Jarad's Orders I do love fetch and this is both fetch,mill, and sift combined together. Not sure if its worth it though
Spider Spawning A great lategame card to use but doesn't really work as well with the big creatures in this deck.

Blue Cards that Fit:
Armored Skaab This has been a staple of mine for awhile and I forgot to include it in the OP. Utterly reliable card.
Tracker's Instinct Not really a blue card but its flashback cost is what makes the card worthwhile
Sleep I've used it to help control the board and let my big fatties swing but I was never that enticed by it.

Hmm, after the analysis it certainly looks as though I have fewer blue card that i'll miss. Armoured Skaab will be the big loss but I think that Grisly Salvage more then makes up for his depature. Okay here is my new list and my rebirth (fiting for Golgari) as a B/G deck!

Lands (22 x ):
4 x Evolving Wilds
4 x Overgrown Tomb
4 x Woodland Cemetery
5 x Forest
5 x Swamp

Creatures (28 x ):
4 x Deathrite Shaman
4 x Dawntreader Elk
2 x Korozda Guildmage
2 x Boneyard Wurm
4 x Dreg Mangler
4 x Splinterfright
2 x Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord
2 x Deadbridge Goliath
4 x Ghoultree


Other Spells (10 x ):
4 x Mulch
4 x Grisly Salvage
2 x Gnaw to the Bone

 
I think i'm pretty happy with this deck though it seems as though it could get pretty expensive. The dual lands have always been hard to obtain in my limited experience. Still its a goal to work towards! What d you guys think?