Community

Okay, the full SoM spoiler is out, prerelease is tomorrow, the cards are hitting Gatherer as I type (yay autocards!), people are posting threads in the MP forum with SoM cards in them... I'm calling it as time for this thread.

The Rules:

1. Tell me which card(s) from SoM are the best in your multiplayer environment. The ones that are going to win you MP games, or turn your playgroup on its head.
2. I'll keep tally here.
3. I vote first. Nyah.

The Tally

---

5 Votes
Exsanguinate

1 Vote
Bellowing Tanglewurm
Blunt the Assault
Carnifex Demon
Chimeric Mass
Culling Dais
Genesis Wave
Glimmerpoint Stag
Liquimetal Coating
Skinrender
Sword of Body and Mind

There's a lot of really fantastic looking stuff in this set in all colors - from White , Blue , Black , Red , Green , Multi-Colored and, obviously, Colorless .

If I had to name one, it would ultimately come down to Precursor Golem vs Chimeric Mass .  Both can go into any deck, which greatly ups their usefulness.  Chimeric Mass is fetchable with Trinket Mage (with swanky new art to boot) while Precursor Golem is insane with anything that targets (I'm looking at you, Rite of Replication ).  My vote has to be with the Chimera , though, since it'll be a massive beater that will animate to win attrition wars post Wrath and post Geddon .

Exsanguinate gets my vote. That card blows my mind. As per usual, here's my take on how the set affects Black:

Blistergrub
A mindly evasive beater with a semi-relevant ability. Pretty weak overall, much like Infectious Horror is. Not really worth using.

Carnifex Demon
This is a very intriguing card, and it falls very much in line with what Black mages want to accomplish. It's very agressively costed at 6 mana, as the card itself is essentially a 6/6 flyer. The obviously synergy is with Proliferate, turning him into a walking Mutilate essentially, and he combos amazingly well himself. With 2 of these out, you can wipe the board every turn.However, I think his best home will be in Wither decks featuring Necroskitter , Crumbling Ashes , Kulrath Knight , etc. He's Midnight Banshee 5-8 in my mind. Not a game breaker, but he'll certainly find homes around the kitchen table.

Exsanguinate
O.O Wow. Woooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooow. I've been championing Bond of Agony on these forums for the better part of a year now stating how good it is as a finisher. This card... blows my freaking mind. I really can't even compare it to Syphon Soul or Blood Tithe because it's a joke to even try to. Every Black player NEEDS 4 of these because every multiplayer Black deck or every deck even playing Black should seriously consider running these monsters. It doesn't even target so say good bye to Ivory Mask decks running you over. Pick these things up! When your friends buy boxes and have tons of extra uncommons, ask for these. This card in the single best money investment and wholly worth buying. I wish I had something really insightful to say about this card, but it's just sheer power. It's one of those absurd Balance -esque spells that is just devastating no matter what. I'm just shocked that Wizards actually printed this, because it's going to break my big mana, Maga, Traitor to Mortals EDH deck in half.

Geth, Lord of the Vault
This is the kind of card that will likely get hated out and unceremoniously killed on sight, and the high mana cost and no protection really doesn't dissuade that course of action. Still, it's an evasive beater with an incredible ability that can allow it to single handidly win games. EDH players in particular know how much artifact acceleration is used, and reviving that and then reviving an army will just make this guy a must have for Black EDH decks. Cabal Coffers , Nirkana Revenant and much more can all allow Black mages to generate enormous sums of mana, and so this monster has so much potential. The strongest thing that this card has going for it, in my mind, is that it's a zombie. I say that because if you don't have 100 ways of reviving him, like Lord of the Undead or Unholy Grotto + Graveborn Muse , backed up by say Oversold Cemetery and maybe Phyrexian Reclamation , he's never going to stay in play long enough to do anything. Zombies also have lots of relevant lords to reduce his mana cost and buff his p/t, making him that much harder to kill and also that much of a stronger beater (he is a 5/5 with evasion for 6 after all).

Ichor Rats
Very strong candidate for any poison counter, proliferate based deck. More often than not this card will come down, start the poison counter madness, and then scare off potential attacks with that 2 power + Infect.If nothing else it'll trade and/or cripple something trying to mess with you.

Painful Quandary
This is one of those cards that I'm torn on. Usually when I read a Black card, I can instantly tell if I'll love it or hate it for multiplayer. That wasn't the case for this one. I know it may seem like an obvious multiplayer bomb, but it's really not. If you like it for the discard, why not use Oppression instead? If you like it for the life loss, why not use say Quest for the Nihil Stone and such that punish people for having no cards in hand? I guess I've always hated choice, and this is a card that let's your opponent decide their own fate. I think that I would have preferred a card that cost 4 mana and only caused 3 life loss or something similar. At 5 mana, it feels too slow to really be a game breaker, especially since you can't pick the effect you'll be getting. I can't say it's a bad card, but I think it'll be an overhyped card that won't see much play in the long run.

Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon
This is, in my opinion, the gem of set for Black. It's given it an entirely new tool in the form of a fearsome dragon that oozes flavor. Before I even discuss the card's abilities, just look at the basics. It's a 5 mana 4/4 flying with Infect. That is fearsome. This creature kills in 3 attacks, even though it's only going to be 2 for all intents and purposes. Proliferate and such will always take care of the last 2 counters. At 5 mana, in a color with Dark Ritual , that is INSANE. Imagine powering him out on turn 3 and killing someone by turn 5 or so. You've committed nothing and already taken someone out. That's just where it starts though, because the card only gets better from here. For a single black mana, we can give this guy haste! Some people will look at this and think "so what, it just means that on turn 6 and on he has haste?" No! We are playing Black, and Black has by far the best revival in the game. Be it Oversold Cemetery or Phyrexian Reclamation , we can revive this badboy every time he's killed and swing with our hasted, 2-3 hit killing machine! You want to block him? So be it, you get -4/-4 forever, so if you're not dead, you're crippled. In Proliferate decks this may as well be an instant kill. Now, conceivably a creature like Baneslayer Angel could have blocked and killed this guy with First Strike, but that's where his last ability comes into play. For 2 mana we can regenrate him too? Are you insane? There's almost nothing out there that do anything to stop this monster. Sure, Commander Eesha , but let's get real. This is the kind of card that break playgroups, because suddenly the people who gain infinite life and play Wrath of God look at this card and cry when they realize that it gets past everything. You will see this creature as an EDH general and you will see him at your kitchen table games, because this is something altogether special from what Black has seen before.

Argentum Armor , Steel Hellkite , Ratchet Bomb , Lux Cannon
Anytime there's an artifact that can destroy artifacts and/or enchantments, I consider it to be a good card for Black. It's so hard to do that without blowing up the world, as we see in All is Dust , Oblivion Stone , etc. This card gives you the option to destroy say Ivory Mask , but not your own Necropotence , which I like a lot. It's something to keep in your pocket.

Chimeric Mass
Beautiful, beautiful card for black mages. It's so easy to lay this card down at 5 counters or so and simply Pox and Smallpox everyone's lands away while you beat away with your 5/5 fueled by a Charcoal Diamond / The problem with old cards like Chimeric Idol was that they needed tons of mana at all times, and so black mages couldn't Death Cloud everyone's lands away and then use them to win. This one only needs 1 mana, and so you can make it huge with Cabal Coffers , and even if you lose all your lands, by your own hand or not ( Balance getting you down?), you can still swing with a gargantuan creature.

Clone Shell
Wanna cheat Emrakul, the Aeons Torn into play? Clone Shell + Vampiric Tutor / Cruel Tutor / Liliana Vess / Insidious Dreams / Sensei's Divining Top / Crystal Ball ... you get the idea. It's so easy to stack your deck playing Black and use this Clone to cheat your your most powerful creature into play.

Contagion Clasp + Contagion Engine + Throne of Geth
These are the perfect cards for your Black wither decks featuring Crumbling Ashes , Midnight Banshee , Necroskitter , etc. They're both proliferate engines and both help with the -1/-1 counter theme. They're obvious great for poison counter decks too, and can make lowly creatures like Ichor Rats game enders after a few turns. It's always nice to help your Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon kill in 2 hits instead of 3, if you can't find a good way to constantly boost his power to at least 5.

Platinum Emperion
Well, it lets Ad Nauseam draw your entire deck if you want, but makes cards like Yawgmoth's Bargain useless. Overall not a very good card. I just want to say how much I dislike cards like this and Platinum Angel , especially in black decks, and that I don't suggest using them.

Venser's Journal
Necropotence and Yawgmoth's Bargain both say hello. A must have for every Black mage.

Wurmcoil Engine
Other than being an auto include in every EDH deck, just remember how powerful this card is with revival in general. Phyrexian Reclamation will cost you 2 life to revive what? 9 life worth of lifelink power? This is just an insane card for every color, but it's even more insane if you can revive it every turn.

This is no contest: Exsanguinate

Now since I personally am of the opinion that it is absurd that they printed that (like black needed such a card to be good, black is one of the best multiplayer colors) and I will ban it from every game I ever play because it is lame to loose to a big coffeepot powered X spell ( Consume Spirit even hardly sees play because it is such a cheap trick).

So I will also name my personal favorite: Ezuri, Renegade Leader
What else did you expect? My nickname in some playgroups isn't Elfboy for nothing. He also is legendary making my Tolsimir Wolfblood EDH deck loose it's white as soon as I have him.

 

Exsanguinate is clearly the best multiplayer card from Scars.  It's just disgustingly good.

Kuldotha Phoenix is probably a card that I like more than I should.  A big, hasty, recursive flyer just makes me smile.

Genesis Wave will probably become the new green ramp spell of choice.  Even flopping out 4 or 5 permanents should be pretty solid.

Liquimetal Coating is probably my favorite new card.  It's an innocent looking card that can have a myriad of uses.  I know I'll be playing it in red decks along with Viashino Heretic and Shattering Pulse .  Finally, a way for red to give a big middle finger to enchantments!

Precursor Golem is going to see many tricks involving many colors.  Plus, he's a solid enough creature that you don't even need to run anything tricky with him.

Wurmcoil Engine is a card I expect to show up A LOT.  It's aggresively costed, it's not limited by color, it doesn't mind (maybe even likes) to die, and, as an artifact and a creature, it can be recurred by every color.  It's very good.