Community

hmm

Niche wrote:

Well based on that staggering statistic I'd say it still shouldn't count as a DtB. 10 isn't much higher than 6 considering the quantity of regionals that were held. Did anyone *win* a regionals with it? What was the list, as I think it'd be very important to post it here if we're trying to get this into the DtB sub-forum.

Here are the decklists from Regionals. The link from SCG won't work for some reason, but you should be able to find the QnT decks pretty quickly.

And day 2 Hollywood isn't to be discounted, but I thought none of the lists even broke top 20?

GWT got 13th and Bucher got 17th.

My single opinion is irrelevant in determining whether or not this is to become a DtB. But I am basing my evaluation on what I've read on stickies on how a deck becomes a DtB, not just conjecture.

The sticky now just mentions tournaments results, but i do remember there being an old sticky before that said how DtBs were chosen. Maybe that one said something different.

As a final point, I only volunteered my local meta because its typically a perfect slice of a PT and it out-strips what we'd call a FNM in competitive play by leaps and bounds.... and while it wasn't meant to be an end-all be-all piece of evidence to support my point, the data I've collected (if you will) from it is relevant. But I won't mention it again.

I agree that it is relevant. It is probably useful to the people discussing the deck. Its just that it isn't really important to deciding whether QnT deserves to go in the subforum.

Here's my latest list, in case I ever decide to run QnT at FNM again (aka let every single match go to time and extra turns).

Quick 'n Toast

Lands - 2 x 4
4 x *Vivid Grove
4 x *Vivid Creek
4 x *Reflecting Pool
3 x *Flooded Grove
2 x *Mystic Gate
2 x *Sunken Ruins
2 x *Dreadship Reef
1 x *Fungal Reaches
1 x *Fire-lit Thicket

Creatures - 1 x 6
4 x *Wall of Roots
4 x *Mulldrifter
3 x *Kitchen Finks
3 x *Cloudthresher
2 x *Chameleon Colossus

Other - 2 x 0
4 x *Rune Snag
4 x *Cryptic Command
4 x *Firespout
3 x *Makeshift Mannequin
3 x *Careful Consideration
2 x *Slaughter Pact

Sideboard - 1 x 5
3 x *Murderous Redcap
3 x *Mind Shatter
3 x *Primal Command
3 x *Teferi's Moat
1 x *Oona, Queen of the Fae
1 x *Chameleon Colossus
1 x *Kitchen Finks

Oona's in there for decks that you know are running Terror and to swap out for threshers in matchups where it sucks.

Colossus is a beating. And, oh yeah, he's the card that this deck can never let resolve against it anyways. More QnT decks should run him.

If the manabase sucks, it's my problem because I'm horrible with those.

EDIT: Forgot to sideboard Graveyard hate . I gotta figure out where that's going.