Community

This thread is for discussion of this week's Top Decks, which goes live Thursday morning on magicthegathering.com.

Legacy player here. Flores, if you're reading this...

In the Dreadstill deck: turn two Standstill can be bad, yes, but it's generally not an optimal play. Threshold decks of most splash colors (white, black, five color, Swans of Bryn Argoll with red) can just Brainstorm into it at the end of the Dreadstill player's turn to force him to discard. Plus, most blue-based Legacy decks run four Daze, four Force of Will at a minimum, so it can be downright deadly for the Dreadstill player to go turn-two Standstill into the opponent's Brainstorm, then basically lose when the opponent untaps and drops a Counterbalance of his own with counter backup (or get forced into racing if Goyf comes down...2/3 Goyf at minimum, likely 3/4 due to high density of fetchlands).

In the Stax deck (the white one): Going to time is the biggest drawback of white Stax - well, that and the lack of card drawing and library manipulation in a format packed with it. Most good mono-white Stax decks run Exalted Angel to speed up the clock. Also, if you think that deck is cool, there's a blue version that uses Tezzeret as its win with Mana Vortex as its 'Geddon analog.

In the Aggro-Loam deck: well, you hit that one on the head, but I'd add that some of those numbers are downright weird by Legacy standards...shocklands? 3 Wasteland? 2 Confidant? Odd.

In the last deck: That deck goes by "Team America," and it's the tempo-oriented evolution of black Threshold. Snuff Out sees zero play in this format outside of just this deck, so Tombstalker being impervious to it is rarely relevant. Most commonly played removal spells either can't touch it because of its size (burn spells, Smother, Pernicious Deed, Engineered Explosives, etc.), or sweep it out of the way without a problem (Swords to Plowshares, Vedalken Shackles, bounce). It's still a good creature regardless, I just though I'd point that out.

The presence of these four decks in particular is certainly interesting. I'd like to know who told Paul Cheon that Dreadstill is a good deck...it puts up the numbers, but it has a reputation of being a bit of a joke deck. It's kind of unfortunate that the Aggro Loam deck didn't get anywhere, though. I don't think Stax is good for it, but it generally does well against everything but combo. Then again, with shocklands and only two Bobs, I can see why it lost.

It's also interesting that there was no straight Threshold, just Team America. Threshold is the best deck in the format despite every deck having a 60% or better Threshold matchup, even Threshold decks.* I'd be interested to know where these guys did their research.

Also, it was incredibly refreshing to see Paul Cheon admit he knew nothing about Legacy personally, and to just discuss the deck instead of pretending to be an expert on the format. BDM's "lol wut legacy u r such a joke format" attitude is always depressing though. Thanks for not doing the same here!

Just chipping in. I know jack **** about Standard and Extended since I don't play those formats (though I hear Faeries is where it's at?).

*This is obviously false, despite what the non-Thresh decks' creators say.

Anyone else got sick from all the pro-USA stuff in this article, beginning with title?

Otherwise solid stuff as usual.