Search
Login
|
Signup
Featured
People
Blogs
Photos
Videos
Groups
Forums
Chat
Wiki
Community
Signup
Login
Search
All Forums
This Forum
Go
Forum Home
Content View
Magic: The Gathering
Rules Theory and Templating
Jump Menu:
Forum Home
Dungeons & Dragons
- D&D Next
-- Official News & Announcements
-- Dungeon Master Playtest Session Feedback
-- Player Playtest Session Feedback
-- Playtest Packet Discussion
-- D&D Next General Discussion
- D&D Products
-- D&D Future Releases
-- D&D Board Games
--- Dungeon Command
-- D&D Insider
-- Third Party and Officially Licensed Products
- D&D Community
-- What's a DM to Do?
-- What's a Player to Do?
-- 4e General Discussion
-- 4e Rules Q&A
-- 4e Character Optimization
-- 4e Character Development
-- Community Business
-- Off-Topic Tavern
-- D&D Gamer Classifieds
--- Online Games
--- US: East of the Mississippi
--- US: West of the Mississippi
--- Canada
--- Europe
--- Asia, Australia and Oceania
--- Central and South America and Africa
- D&D Worlds
-- Homebrew Campaigns
-- Dark Sun
-- Eberron
-- Forgotten Realms
-- Gamma World
-- Nentir Vale and Beyond
-- Other Published Worlds
--- Dragonlance
--- Birthright
--- Mystara
--- Planescape
--- Ravenloft
--- Spelljammer
--- Greyhawk
--- Oriental Adventures
--- Other Worlds (Including 3rd Party)
- 4e Errata
-- Print Material
-- Dragon and Dungeon articles
-- 4E Errata Archive
- D&D Previous Editions
-- Previous Editions General
-- Previous Editions Character Optimization
-- Non-D&D TSR and WotC RPG Discussion
-- RPGs General Discussion
-- Previous Editions Archive
Magic: The Gathering
- Magic Help
-- Rules Q&A
--- FAQs and Reference
-- New and Returning Player Forum
- General Community
-- Magic General
-- Daily MtG Article Discussion
-- Magic Forums Business
- Card Discussion
-- Cards and Combos
-- Future Card and Set Speculation
-- You Make the Card
- Digital Games
-- M:TG - Duels of the Planeswalkers
-- Magic Online
- Creative Discussion
-- Flavor and Storylines
-- Magic Art and Artists
- Advanced Theory
-- Rules Theory and Templating
-- Design & Development Theory
- Casual Play
-- Casual Decks
-- Multiplayer
-- Commander (EDH)
-- Cube Draft
- Tournament Play
-- Standard General
--- Standard Deck Help
--- Standard Tournament Center: Tier 1
--- Standard Tournament Center: Tier 2
-- Extended General
--- Extended Deck Help
--- Extended Tournament Center
-- Block Constructed
--- Decks to Beat
-- Legacy
--- Decks to Beat
-- Vintage
--- Decks to Beat
-- Limited (Sealed and Draft)
-- Modern General
--- Modern Deck Help
- Sanctioned Events
-- Event Announcements
-- Event Discussion
- Retired Magic Forums
-- You Make the Comic!
-- Tribal Wars
-- Magic Player Rewards
-- Friday Night Magic
-- Prerelease Tourneys
-- Pro Tour and Pro Tour Qualifiers
-- Grand Prix
-- Planeswalker Points
-- City Champs, Regionals, Nationals, and Worlds
Magic Online
- Game Help
-- New Player Forum
-- Magic Online Bugs and Technical Issues
- Magic Online HQ
-- Magic Online General
-- MTGO Formats - Tournament
-- MTGO Formats - Recreational
- Community Section
-- Clans & Recruitment
-- Tranquil Thicket
-- Magic Online Player Run Events
-- Magic Online Customization
- Magic Online Retired Forums
-- Announcements
-- Client Interface Questions
-- Event Requests and Discussion
-- Contests
-- Magic Online Announcements
-- Deck Critique: MTGO Formats
-- Deck Critique: MTGO Formats
--- Limited
--- Classic
--- Commander (100 Card Singleton)
--- Pauper
--- Singleton
--- Tribal (Classic)
--- 2HG MTGO
--- Misc/Other/New Format Ideas
--- Online Legacy
-- Magic Online Technical Issues
-- Prismatic
-- Kaleidoscope
-- Magic Online Championship Series
-- Vanguard
-- Boards Business
-- Magic Online Feature Suggestions
Avalon Hill
- Avalon Hill Board Games
-- Avalon Hill Classic and Modern Board Games
-- Diplomacy
- Axis and Allies Board Games
-- Axis and Allies Board Games General
-- Axis & Allies Board Games Q&A
- Axis and Allies Miniatures
-- Axis and Allies Minis General
-- Axis and Allies Minis Naval Miniatures
-- Axis and Allies Air Force Miniatures
-- Axis and Allies Scenarios and Campaigns
-- Axis and Allies Painting and Modeling
-- A&A Minis Q&A
- Avalon Hill HQ
-- AH Boards Business
-- Gamer Classifieds
-- Tournaments and Events
D&D Miniatures
- D&D Miniatures HQ
-- Painting & Modeling
-- D&D Miniatures General
--- "Guy's Rulings" Archive
-- Tournaments
-- Warband Critique
-- D&D Minis Gen Con Reports
-- Community Business
Star Wars®
- Star Wars Community HQ
-- Community Business
-- Mos Eisley Cantina
-- Tosche Station
- Star Wars® Minis HQ
-- Star Wars® Miniatures General
--- Starship Battles General
-- Star Wars® Minis Rules
-- Squad Critique
-- Custom Minis, Maps, and Stats
- Star Wars® RPG HQ
-- The Mess Hall
--- Dawn of Defiance
-- The Senate
-- The Temple
-- The Praxeum
- Star Wars® TCG HQ
-- Star Wars® TCG General
General Gaming
- General Gaming HQ
-- The Rec Room (Non-Gaming Discussion)
--- Rec Room Posting Games
-- General Gaming Discussion
-- Community Contests & Events
-- General Gaming Forums Community Business
- Creative Corner
-- Community Art
-- Community Magazine Forum
-- Once Upon a Time
-- Community World Creation
- Play-by-Post and Roleplaying
-- Real Adventures: Setup Zone
-- The Castle of Fun
-- Terisia City and Fan Fiction
-- Coalition War Game
-- The Map of the Planes
-- Garic's City
-- Magic Puzzles, Fun, & Games!
-- The Gathering Storm
-- d20 Modern Games
-- The COre COliseum
-- The Guild House
-- Gleemax Roleplaying
-- Play-by-Post Haven
-- Paranoia Paradise
-- Real Adventures: Real Fantasy
-- Legends of the Guilds
- Real Adventures: Real Sci-Fi/Modern
WIZARDS.COMmunity
- Community HQ
-- Community Business Board
-- Community Announcements
-- VCL Coordination
-- Volunteer Community Lead Program Open Discussion
- The Marketplace
-- Axis and Allies Minis Tradehouse
-- D&D Minis Tradehouse
-- Dreamblade Player Classifieds
-- Duel Masters Cards
-- Magic Cards
-- Magic Online Cards
-- RPG Marketplace
-- Star Wars® Minis Tradehouse
-- Star Wars® Cards
-- TCG Gamer Classifieds
- Dreamblade Minis Tradehouse
- Legacy Forums
-- Hecatomb Rules Q&A
-- Deck Critique
-- Transformers 3D Battle Card Game
-- U:GG Discussion
-- Gleemax
-- Gaming Industry Jobs
-- Gleemax Games Alpha General Discussion
-- Family Gaming
-- GenCon 2008 Blogs
-- Legacy Staff Blogs
- Hecatomb General
WPN
- DCI HQ
-- DCI Tournament Organizer General
-- DCI Reporter Software
-- Wizards Play Network
RPGA
- RPGA HQ
-- RPGA General
-- RPGA Conventions
- RPGA Campaigns
-- Living Forgotten Realms
--- LFR Adventures Discussion
--- LFR Character Discussion
- RPGA Legacy Forums
-- Living Greyhawk
--- Living Greyhawk Rules
--- Living Greyhawk Characters
-- Mark of Heroes
-- Xen'drik Expeditions
--- Covenant of Light
--- Blackwheel Company
--- Cabal of Shadows
--- Crimson Codex
Dreamblade
- dreamblademinis.com
- Dreamblade HQ
-- Dreamblade General
-- Dreamblade Rules Q&A
-- Warband Critique
-- Strategy
-- Tournament Play
New Thread
Page
1
of
60
•
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
60
Next
Go
Threads in Forum: Rules Theory and Templating
Thread
Replies
Views
Last Post
Orb and Master Errata: Why not the same for LED and Lotus Vale?
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
32
33
34
35
36
37
Started By:
ConcernedPlayer
368
19,256
2 years ago
by
Natedogg
Changes with Magic:2010
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
36
37
38
39
40
41
Started By:
Skibo_the_first
404
18,535
4 years ago
by
Qmark
Oracle/Gatherer Errors and Fixes - Avacyn Restored
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
26
27
28
29
30
31
Started By:
WotC_MattT
305
15,628
1 year ago
by
WotC_MattT
January 2012 IPG Revisions
1
2
3
4
5
6
Started By:
WotC_MattT
56
13,428
1 year ago
by
jeff-heikkinen
Oracle and Gatherer Ruling Changes - Dark Ascension
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
11
12
13
14
15
16
Started By:
WotC_MattT
154
10,198
1 year ago
by
Avedomni
Protection from All Colors
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Started By:
Saethori
64
9,524
4 years ago
by
rocketnia
Hexproof Dies.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Started By:
TranscientMaster
99
8,301
2 years ago
by
Kedar
Trample vs. Damage Prevention
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Started By:
darkeshrine
101
8,222
11 months ago
by
Casfairlane
Just say no to stupid rulings!
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
15
16
17
18
19
20
Started By:
KevinStanton77
190
8,112
5 years ago
by
zammm
Gatherer Errors - Outdated Rulings and Oracle Typos
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
12
13
14
15
16
17
Started By:
zammm
161
7,786
2 years ago
by
WotC_MattT
Without Paying X
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Started By:
zammm
106
7,110
3 years ago
by
GoblinBasar
For Discussion: Manaweaving before shuffling should be explicitly banned
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
12
13
14
15
16
17
Started By:
dlthe
168
6,841
1 year ago
by
DocDoom
Protection from everything
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Started By:
Rush_Clasic
90
6,752
4 years ago
by
2goth4U
I concede (in a multi-player game played for Ante)
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
13
14
15
16
17
18
Started By:
Ahlyis
174
6,586
4 years ago
by
zammm
Lake of the Dead Question
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Started By:
missingcalculus
117
6,203
3 years ago
by
Merestil_Haye
Failure to Draw
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Started By:
zammm
90
6,120
2 years ago
by
Nyktos
Just wondering hypothetically
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Started By:
jayhoegh
118
5,980
4 years ago
by
jeff-heikkinen
Timing and conflicting simultanous effects
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
12
13
14
15
16
17
Started By:
syren.oldskool
169
5,687
3 years ago
by
Natedogg
trample with deathtouch. Does it do what they said, or how it should work?
1
2
3
Started By:
Kaya_Kenobi
23
5,681
1 year ago
by
Gemstone386
More general effects with durations (eg Oblivion Ring)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Started By:
rmsgrey
104
5,658
11 months ago
by
Astarael7
"Helping your opponent win"
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
8
9
10
11
12
13
Started By:
zammm
124
5,290
1 year ago
by
PirateAmmo
Life gain and poison counters
1
2
3
4
Started By:
Rejoice
32
5,255
2 years ago
by
Skibo_the_first
Neverending Game
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Started By:
missingcalculus
99
5,215
3 years ago
by
zammm
Attribute of a card
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
8
9
10
11
12
13
Started By:
niheloim
128
5,101
2 years ago
by
niheloim
Hexproof
1
2
Started By:
Kedar
11
5,087
1 year ago
by
Trolljuju
Maximum Handsize Template
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
10
11
12
13
14
15
Started By:
deathregis
141
5,063
2 years ago
by
Skibo_the_first
Gatherer Oddities and Errors (again)
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
8
9
10
11
12
13
Started By:
SyntheticDreamer
126
4,915
10 hours ago
by
deathregis
212.3g vs 420.5c
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Started By:
2goth4U
105
4,912
4 years ago
by
MystErikEry
Persist-Cloning a Tatterkite
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Started By:
rocketnia
87
4,884
4 years ago
by
Just_another_Wizard
Bring Back Damage on the Stack?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Started By:
Specter
98
4,784
1 year ago
by
jeff-heikkinen
Page
1
of
60
•
1
2
3
4
5
6
...
60
Next
Go
Jump Menu:
Forum Home
Dungeons & Dragons
- D&D Next
-- Official News & Announcements
-- Dungeon Master Playtest Session Feedback
-- Player Playtest Session Feedback
-- Playtest Packet Discussion
-- D&D Next General Discussion
- D&D Products
-- D&D Future Releases
-- D&D Board Games
--- Dungeon Command
-- D&D Insider
-- Third Party and Officially Licensed Products
- D&D Community
-- What's a DM to Do?
-- What's a Player to Do?
-- 4e General Discussion
-- 4e Rules Q&A
-- 4e Character Optimization
-- 4e Character Development
-- Community Business
-- Off-Topic Tavern
-- D&D Gamer Classifieds
--- Online Games
--- US: East of the Mississippi
--- US: West of the Mississippi
--- Canada
--- Europe
--- Asia, Australia and Oceania
--- Central and South America and Africa
- D&D Worlds
-- Homebrew Campaigns
-- Dark Sun
-- Eberron
-- Forgotten Realms
-- Gamma World
-- Nentir Vale and Beyond
-- Other Published Worlds
--- Dragonlance
--- Birthright
--- Mystara
--- Planescape
--- Ravenloft
--- Spelljammer
--- Greyhawk
--- Oriental Adventures
--- Other Worlds (Including 3rd Party)
- 4e Errata
-- Print Material
-- Dragon and Dungeon articles
-- 4E Errata Archive
- D&D Previous Editions
-- Previous Editions General
-- Previous Editions Character Optimization
-- Non-D&D TSR and WotC RPG Discussion
-- RPGs General Discussion
-- Previous Editions Archive
Magic: The Gathering
- Magic Help
-- Rules Q&A
--- FAQs and Reference
-- New and Returning Player Forum
- General Community
-- Magic General
-- Daily MtG Article Discussion
-- Magic Forums Business
- Card Discussion
-- Cards and Combos
-- Future Card and Set Speculation
-- You Make the Card
- Digital Games
-- M:TG - Duels of the Planeswalkers
-- Magic Online
- Creative Discussion
-- Flavor and Storylines
-- Magic Art and Artists
- Advanced Theory
-- Rules Theory and Templating
-- Design & Development Theory
- Casual Play
-- Casual Decks
-- Multiplayer
-- Commander (EDH)
-- Cube Draft
- Tournament Play
-- Standard General
--- Standard Deck Help
--- Standard Tournament Center: Tier 1
--- Standard Tournament Center: Tier 2
-- Extended General
--- Extended Deck Help
--- Extended Tournament Center
-- Block Constructed
--- Decks to Beat
-- Legacy
--- Decks to Beat
-- Vintage
--- Decks to Beat
-- Limited (Sealed and Draft)
-- Modern General
--- Modern Deck Help
- Sanctioned Events
-- Event Announcements
-- Event Discussion
- Retired Magic Forums
-- You Make the Comic!
-- Tribal Wars
-- Magic Player Rewards
-- Friday Night Magic
-- Prerelease Tourneys
-- Pro Tour and Pro Tour Qualifiers
-- Grand Prix
-- Planeswalker Points
-- City Champs, Regionals, Nationals, and Worlds
Magic Online
- Game Help
-- New Player Forum
-- Magic Online Bugs and Technical Issues
- Magic Online HQ
-- Magic Online General
-- MTGO Formats - Tournament
-- MTGO Formats - Recreational
- Community Section
-- Clans & Recruitment
-- Tranquil Thicket
-- Magic Online Player Run Events
-- Magic Online Customization
- Magic Online Retired Forums
-- Announcements
-- Client Interface Questions
-- Event Requests and Discussion
-- Contests
-- Magic Online Announcements
-- Deck Critique: MTGO Formats
-- Deck Critique: MTGO Formats
--- Limited
--- Classic
--- Commander (100 Card Singleton)
--- Pauper
--- Singleton
--- Tribal (Classic)
--- 2HG MTGO
--- Misc/Other/New Format Ideas
--- Online Legacy
-- Magic Online Technical Issues
-- Prismatic
-- Kaleidoscope
-- Magic Online Championship Series
-- Vanguard
-- Boards Business
-- Magic Online Feature Suggestions
Avalon Hill
- Avalon Hill Board Games
-- Avalon Hill Classic and Modern Board Games
-- Diplomacy
- Axis and Allies Board Games
-- Axis and Allies Board Games General
-- Axis & Allies Board Games Q&A
- Axis and Allies Miniatures
-- Axis and Allies Minis General
-- Axis and Allies Minis Naval Miniatures
-- Axis and Allies Air Force Miniatures
-- Axis and Allies Scenarios and Campaigns
-- Axis and Allies Painting and Modeling
-- A&A Minis Q&A
- Avalon Hill HQ
-- AH Boards Business
-- Gamer Classifieds
-- Tournaments and Events
D&D Miniatures
- D&D Miniatures HQ
-- Painting & Modeling
-- D&D Miniatures General
--- "Guy's Rulings" Archive
-- Tournaments
-- Warband Critique
-- D&D Minis Gen Con Reports
-- Community Business
Star Wars®
- Star Wars Community HQ
-- Community Business
-- Mos Eisley Cantina
-- Tosche Station
- Star Wars® Minis HQ
-- Star Wars® Miniatures General
--- Starship Battles General
-- Star Wars® Minis Rules
-- Squad Critique
-- Custom Minis, Maps, and Stats
- Star Wars® RPG HQ
-- The Mess Hall
--- Dawn of Defiance
-- The Senate
-- The Temple
-- The Praxeum
- Star Wars® TCG HQ
-- Star Wars® TCG General
General Gaming
- General Gaming HQ
-- The Rec Room (Non-Gaming Discussion)
--- Rec Room Posting Games
-- General Gaming Discussion
-- Community Contests & Events
-- General Gaming Forums Community Business
- Creative Corner
-- Community Art
-- Community Magazine Forum
-- Once Upon a Time
-- Community World Creation
- Play-by-Post and Roleplaying
-- Real Adventures: Setup Zone
-- The Castle of Fun
-- Terisia City and Fan Fiction
-- Coalition War Game
-- The Map of the Planes
-- Garic's City
-- Magic Puzzles, Fun, & Games!
-- The Gathering Storm
-- d20 Modern Games
-- The COre COliseum
-- The Guild House
-- Gleemax Roleplaying
-- Play-by-Post Haven
-- Paranoia Paradise
-- Real Adventures: Real Fantasy
-- Legends of the Guilds
- Real Adventures: Real Sci-Fi/Modern
WIZARDS.COMmunity
- Community HQ
-- Community Business Board
-- Community Announcements
-- VCL Coordination
-- Volunteer Community Lead Program Open Discussion
- The Marketplace
-- Axis and Allies Minis Tradehouse
-- D&D Minis Tradehouse
-- Dreamblade Player Classifieds
-- Duel Masters Cards
-- Magic Cards
-- Magic Online Cards
-- RPG Marketplace
-- Star Wars® Minis Tradehouse
-- Star Wars® Cards
-- TCG Gamer Classifieds
- Dreamblade Minis Tradehouse
- Legacy Forums
-- Hecatomb Rules Q&A
-- Deck Critique
-- Transformers 3D Battle Card Game
-- U:GG Discussion
-- Gleemax
-- Gaming Industry Jobs
-- Gleemax Games Alpha General Discussion
-- Family Gaming
-- GenCon 2008 Blogs
-- Legacy Staff Blogs
- Hecatomb General
WPN
- DCI HQ
-- DCI Tournament Organizer General
-- DCI Reporter Software
-- Wizards Play Network
RPGA
- RPGA HQ
-- RPGA General
-- RPGA Conventions
- RPGA Campaigns
-- Living Forgotten Realms
--- LFR Adventures Discussion
--- LFR Character Discussion
- RPGA Legacy Forums
-- Living Greyhawk
--- Living Greyhawk Rules
--- Living Greyhawk Characters
-- Mark of Heroes
-- Xen'drik Expeditions
--- Covenant of Light
--- Blackwheel Company
--- Cabal of Shadows
--- Crimson Codex
Dreamblade
- dreamblademinis.com
- Dreamblade HQ
-- Dreamblade General
-- Dreamblade Rules Q&A
-- Warband Critique
-- Strategy
-- Tournament Play
Forum Home
Content View
Magic: The Gathering
Rules Theory and Templating
Viewing this forum :: 0 registered and 3 guests
No registered users viewing
