Latest Update
Sticky topic

Rules T&T - About and FAQ - Started by zammm

Welcome to the Rules Theory and Templating forum!What Belongs HereRules T&T is a specialized forum devoted to metadiscussion of the...

zammm Jan 28, 2010 16:49:00
Normal topic

Some supertypes achachable/atachment - Started by Matt_Holck

Some supertypes   Attachment  ... to ... these describes when one card is attached to another card when cast The...

Matt_Holck 1 hour ago
Hot topic

Mul Daya Channelers - Started by razorborne

how does Mul Daya Channelers work, rules-wise? I ask because of the following: ...

rocketnia 1 hour ago
Normal topic

Ambiguity (Unhinged) - Started by jaspip

Ambiguity was an Unhinged card that made fun of the way that in Magic the same words can have radically different meaning based on...

Matt_Holck Apr 12, 2015 12:29:39
Hot topic

Gatherer Oddities and Errors (again) - Started by SyntheticDreamer

Was looking through an old ruling errors thread from prior to M13 and noticed that a ruling error has not been fixed for the Mirage block...

Page 1, 2, 3... 7, 8
FezzHead Apr 12, 2015 7:09:18
Normal topic

Arcbond: The Way It Should Have Been - Started by Edacade

At least according to someone I play against at FNM on a regular basis.

Shadowchylde Apr 08, 2015 10:57:33
Hot topic

The last ever core set Keyword Wishlist - Started by Highwayman

The rebooted core sets for a brief while became an entry point for introducing new evergreen keywords, or editing old ones. More recent...

Highwayman Apr 07, 2015 8:18:59
Normal topic

Controlling another player's Withengar Unbound / Blood Tyrant - Started by MarioH

Does Withengar Unbound's or Blood Tyrant's ability trigger under another player's control when its owner loses the game?

Astarael7 Apr 01, 2015 2:56:11
Hot topic

Inconsistent Functionality and/or Power-Level Errata - Started by BaconCat

It's been over 18 months (and close to 4 years since the initial reason for this post) since the last time I brought this up with no...

zammm Mar 21, 2015 0:35:56
Normal topic

601.2g: Paying costs - Started by 704.5s

It seems like the details surrounding how costs are paid could be clarified a bit....

zammm Mar 17, 2015 0:17:11
Normal topic

Manifested Bringer - Started by Astarael7

I saw this interaction brought up in a Rules Q&A thread and I thought I'd put it here in case we need official attention for it....

Kedar Feb 16, 2015 19:13:04
Normal topic

Big Mana Symbol on Basic (Snow) Lands - Started by Gemstone386

This may have been explained to me before, but if it has, I do not remember and cannot find the explanation....

Carl_Miller Feb 15, 2015 22:44:36
Normal topic

The Phrase "Permanent Card" - Started by Gemstone386

Some cards use the phrase "permanent card". Since the game defines permanents as things on the battlefield, why does a phrase exist that...

Kedar Feb 14, 2015 13:22:34
Hot topic

Pros on the Instant Supertype - Started by SilverGreen

I'm resurrecting this subject and creating this thread due to an answer from Matt Tabak to a question I submited to his Tumblr. Thanks,...

Page 1, 2, 3, 4
Matt_Holck Jan 30, 2015 11:51:09
Normal topic

Mulligan Rule in Limited - Started by Mufasa22

After playing quite a lot of Magic, one rule, and one rule only,  is still bothering me because of its undesired considerable im...

Mufasa22 Jan 28, 2015 8:02:22
Normal topic

Overburden & Xanthic Statue like artifacts - Started by Tarangil


Matt_Holck Jan 22, 2015 23:52:28
Normal topic

Manifest and DFC's - Started by Rhazgriz

Here are two different, although rarely seen, situations that may happen with the manifest mechanic and other cards....

Guest1553439538 Jan 16, 2015 22:59:58
Normal topic

Discarding hand now obseleted? - Started by Highwayman

I have just noticed that in FRF (no spoiler here) there is the following line of text......

FezzHead Jan 12, 2015 17:04:11
Normal topic

Targetting Cards in Hidden Zones - Started by ttam1024

My friend wanted to create a card, and he used this language to do so:...

ttam1024 Jan 07, 2015 8:40:28
Normal topic

Rain of Gore and mana abilities - Started by Rhazgriz

With the assumption that Rain of Gore interacts with life gain in two different ways depending on what causes the life gain, how does it...

Shadowchylde Jan 04, 2015 23:32:44
Normal topic

Smallpox template problem - Started by Gazbanzo

This appears to affect Smallpox, Rite of Ruin, and Death Cloud since the new Modern Masters wording....

zammm Dec 28, 2014 11:13:18
Normal topic

simplify the EtB replacement effect rule a little bit? - Started by TobyornotToby

So the rules for entering the battlefield replacement effects are a bit convoluted and we have to accept that, but I think Magic can do...

Gazbanzo Dec 26, 2014 15:00:30
Hot topic

Gemstone Mine and Doubling Season - Started by MRHblue

I did search and found a few relevant threads, but none seemed specific enough. Doubling Season does not double the counters on a land...

Page 1, 2
cixidetroy Dec 17, 2014 5:26:15
Normal topic

Allowing a commander to be stolen? - Started by KradWolfe22

In a discussion on "ask a magic judge" chat, I read the ruling on "It that betrays." Basically if I sac a non-token creature then it...

evouga Dec 14, 2014 20:18:27
Normal topic

Cloning a kicked creature - Started by FezzHead

If I Clone a kicked Benalish Lancer, I'm pretty sure the Clone won't get any +1/+1 counters, but will it have first strike?...

WotC_dlaugel Dec 12, 2014 13:02:10
New posts
No new posts
Hot topic with new posts
Hot topic without new posts
Sticky topic
Locked topic
Subscribe to RSS - Rules Theory and Templating