Dawn Charm vs Profane Command

3 posts / 0 new
Last post
Hi all, I met this recently, I cast Profane Command choosing to :target player loses X life; and X target creature gains fear.. Then my opponent casts Dawn Charm choosing to counter target spell that targets you. Can he do it? Thx
Hi all, I met this recently, I cast Profane Command choosing to :target player loses X life; and X target creature gains fear.. Then my opponent casts Dawn Charm choosing to counter target spell that targets you. Can he do it? Thx

Yes, assuming that your opponent was the target for "lose X life". Profane Command targets your opponent - the fact that it also targets some creatures doesn't change that.

The Charm would need to be worded similar to "counter target spell that targets only you" for it to not work against Profane Command.
ok thanks, that's what we agreed..
Sign In to post comments