Healing Surges... another name for a simulationist?

12 posts / 0 new
Last post

Getting back into D&D with 4e.  I quite like a lot of things about 4e, espeically from a DM perspective, but there are also things I don’t like, in particular I can’t rationalize healing surges to myself (or my players).  It seems very video gameish to me. 

Has anyone thought of an alternate name/explanation for healing surges that makes more world sense instead of just mechanically making sense as a balancing tool?  I am OK for clerics to have it - i think that makes sense.  But what is it exactly that is healing a fighter?

Its not a big deal and I can live with it but curious if any discussion or thought have arisen over the years about this.

Healing surges are basically you getting your breath back after a fight.  They're your reserves of endurance for the day.  When you get a chance to sit down and take a breather, you can get back to fighting fitness.

They're intended to be more of an action-movie-type mechanic, than a videogamey one.  Just think Die Hard - when John McClane is getting the heck knocked out of him in a fistfight, he's eating HP damage.  When he finishes off the guy, and sits down and patches up his wounds, wraps bandages round his feet etc, he's spending healing surges.  As he goes through the movie, and he gets progressively more battered and shredded, covered in blood and bruises, and his endurance goes down... That's his healing surges running out.

HP are a 'this-fight' resource.  HS are a 'this-day' resource.

It helps if you think of HP as they're intended - mostly a reserve of luck, endurance, grit and toughness, rather than literally 'each HP is a wound' or whatever.  You're not seriously wounded until you go below 0HP.  You're not out of the fight entirely until you stabilise at below 0, or you hit -bloodied/3DSTs.
Harrying your Prey, the Easy Way: A Hunter's Handbook - the first of what will hopefully be many CharOp efforts on my part. The Blinker - teleport everywhere. An Eladrin Knight/Eldritch Knight. CB != rules source.
Perhaps you could call them Recoveries, which is the 13th Age name for them, if that makes more sense to you and your party.

Regarding what they represent: they are a normalised absolute measure of the character health, independant of levels. So in this model HP are a measure of fatigue/endurance, which scales with levels, while HS gives you the status of how much the character can still take before having to call it a day. 

As a houserule, to make things more gritty, we rule that characters who drops below 0 HP lose a HS for the rest of the adventure (as recovering it would require a very long rest and medical support). 
I like both ideas of losing a surge and the diehard model.  Excellent, that's enougth rationalisation for me.  Thanks.
Well, it's a bit of a read, and you already seem satisfied, but I'm going to leave you this link anyway.  It leads to a blog in which the answer is explored.
Seriously, though, you should check out the PbP Haven. You might also like Real Adventures, IF you're cool.
Knights of W.T.F.- Silver Spur Winner
4enclave, a place where 4e fans can talk 4e in peace.
I prefer the name Heroic Reserves myself. I think it better fits what they represent.
Owner and Proprietor of the House of Trolls. God of ownership and possession.
I love healing surges- one of the aspects that I enjoy in 4th.

Well, it's a bit of a read, and you already seem satisfied, but I'm going to leave you this link anyway.  It leads to a blog in which the answer is explored.

Great read.  D&D has always said hit-points were not lifeforce.  Hit-points is an accumulation of luck, skill etc.  In 1e we said that first level hit-points were the actual physical durability of the character (which is why they were so fragile and why if you got reduced that low you were in trouble and bleeding) and as you went up you got the skill that padded out your survivability. What was sticking in my simulationist mind was the wording "healing surge" and kept picturing healing bubbles around the character.  Which is wrong and my fault.  Fully satisfied with these answers.

Thanks all.

I prefer the name Heroic Reserves myself. I think it better fits what they represent.

Indeed. Healing Surges aren't really video game based, their more like "plot power".
Has anyone thought of an alternate name/explanation for healing surges that makes more world sense

Stamina, endurance, cardio... basically anything that minimizes fatigue. This concept implies that hits on trained/armored adventurers are at worst minor cuts/bruises... until they start getting too tired to avoid injury very well.

4e is pretty hard on simulationism though.
I like to think of HP as the hero's ability to keep fighting. It's a mixture of health, morale and stamina. From that standpoint, healing surges are your innate reserves to rally each of those things. You can only go to the well so many times, eventually even heros run out of gas.
Previous HP references, if anyone desires:
AD&D 1e PHB p.34: "hit points represent how much damage (actual or potential) the character can withstand before being killed. A certain amount of these hit points represent the actual physical punishment which can be sustained. The remainder, a significant portion of hit points at higher levels, stands for skill, luck, and/or magical factors."

AD&D 1e DMG p.61: "Damage scored to characters or certain monsters is actually not substantially physical–a mere nick or scratch until the last handful of hit points are considered–it is a matter of wearing away the endurance, the luck, the magical protections."

D&D 3.5e PHB p.145: "Hit points mean two things in the game world: the ability to take physical punishment and keep going, and the ability to turn a serious blow into a less serious one. For some characters, hit points may represent divine favor or inner power."

D&D 4e PHB p.293: "Hit points represent more than physical endurance. They represent your character’s skill, luck, and resolve—all the factors that combine to help you stay alive in a combat situation."

D&D 5e article Here
In D&D Next, hit points and Hit Dice are an abstraction that we use to model more than just a character's physical durability. In fact, we have three elements that tie into a character's hit points and Hit Dice.

  • Physical capacity for punishment, which is measured through a combination of size, bulk, and durability. An elephant or a hill giant has plenty of hit points due to raw physical endurance and bulk. Big creatures can take a lot of punishment.

  • Energy and experience, which is measured by a creature's ability to turn a direct hit into a glancing blow and ignore minor aches and pains. Frederika, the 10th-level dwarf fighter, can turn even a giant's crushing strike into a near miss. She might take 30 points of damage from the hit, but in terms of physical injury she might not have more than a light bruise. The same attack against Samwell, the 1st-level halfling fighter, turns him into a dead, bloody mess. Poor Samwell lacks the training and experience to avoid the worst of the attack.

  • Luck and cosmic significance, which is the simple truth that in a world of high magic, gods, and planar powers, some creatures are consigned by fate to take on a great task. The sword blow that slays the common soldier is a glancing strike against the hero destined to stand at the center of important events. A white dragon ambushes the wizard Mordenkainen and unleashes a ferocious attack. The wizard avoids death by stepping aside at just the right moment. He might suffer a few cuts, but through luck, coincidence, or fate, he stepped to the side just as the dragon was about to attack.

Here's a brief overview that gives you an idea of what happens when a creature takes damage.

A creature with more than half its maximum hit points has nothing more than the superficial signs of injury. There might be a few tears in its armor or clothes, or it could have a dent in its shield, and it has not yet suffered any serious physical harm beyond a scrape, light cut, or bruise. Anyone looking at the creature likely doesn't notice that it has been involved in a fight.

A creature with less than half its maximum hit points has suffered a few noticeable cuts or bruises. A casual inspection or quick look reveals that the creature has taken a few hits, so it is noticeably injured.

A creature that is reduced to 0 or fewer hit points has suffered a direct hit—enough to knock it unconscious. The attack that dropped it caused a serious injury that might crack bones and cause heavy, ongoing bleeding.

Consider the example of a giant spider attacking a 1st-level fighter who has 10 hit points. The spider's first attack deals 3 damage, and the fighter must make a Constitution saving throw against its poison. The bite barely broke the fighter's skin, but just barely. The mark from the bite will clear up in a day or so. The fighter has a scratch that most people would overlook.

The next bite reduces the fighter to 3 hit points and requires another saving throw. This bite causes a noticeable injury since the fighter now has less than half of his or her hit points. The fighter will wake up the next morning with a scab over the bite, and it might take another couple of days for the injury to disappear. A good rest erases most of the real physical effects of the injury. Anyone looking at the fighter would immediately notice the nasty-looking bite wound.

If the spider drops the fighter, it lands a deadly attack. The wound is vicious and ugly. It bleeds freely, and only prompt attention or sheer luck can save the fighter. If mundane bandages are all the fighter's companions have on hand, it will take a couple of days for the fighter to return to action. At this point, there's a chance that the fighter will have a lasting scar, and he or she needs magic to get back into the fight in the short term.

Also, here are healing references if desired:
D&D (original brown book, volume 3) p.35: "common wounds can be healed with the passage of time (or the use of magics already explained). On the first day of complete rest no hit points will be regained, but every other day thereafter one hit point will be regained until the character is completely healed. This can take a long time."

AD&D 1e PHB p.105: "There are numerous ways to restore lost hit points. The most mundane is by resting and allowing time to do the job. For each day of rest, 1 hit point of damage is restored. After 30 game days have passed, hit points accrue at the rate of 5 per day thereafter."

AD&D 1e DMG p.82: "it is absolutely necessary that the character rest in order to recuperate, i.e. any combat, spell using, or similar activity does not constitute rest, so no hit points can be regained. For each day of rest a character will regain 1 hit point"

D&D 3.5e PHB p.146: "With a full night’s rest (8 hours of sleep or more), you recover 1 hit point per character level."

fwiw: since 4e allows players to refluff stuff without changing the mechanics, I allow death to be described more as 'severely wounded'. The PC's injuries are severe enough to prevent him from taking any actions until he can access some stronger, costlier (500gp) healing.
Sign In to post comments