Question about Divine Reckoning [ISD]

3 posts / 0 new
Last post
Do players choose which creature to keep when Divine Reckoning is cast or when it is resolved?

For example, in a multiplayer EDH game I have Vish Kal, Blood Arbiter and a few other creatures when I cast Divine Reckoning. Can I know what creatures my opponents have chosen if I respond to Divine Reckoning by sacrificing my doomed creatures and doling out -X/-X to the creatures my opponents chose to keep?
you cannot respond to the choice
when players choose a creature it means Divine Reckoning has started resolving
the next time you get priority is when it is done resolving

you can of course sacrifice all creatures except Vish Kal to load him up and then when Divine Reckoning is done use him to finish the survivor
proud member of the 2011 community team
Thank you