indestructible and trample

4 posts / 0 new
Last post
Last night one of my freinds and I while playing came across this and wasnt sure how it would go.

I had Avacyn, Angel of Hope defending agaist a 10/10 Clockwork Dragon with trample. Since avacyn cant be destroyed by leathal damagae I said all 10 of the power went onto her ending combat there, since she didnt receive leathal damgae nothing rolled over onto me. My freind is saying that she can only block 8 of it and other two rolls on to me. 

Anythoughts on how this would play out?

The game doesn't consider such things when assigning damage. As always, you need to assign at least as much damage as would be required to be lethal damage (the damage receiver's toughness minus any damage already marked on it, or 1 if the damage dealer has deathtouch), then any excess can be assigned to the player.

Your friend is correct.

Trample works in the assignment of damage, not after the damage is dealt.

It doesn't care nor knows if the creature will survive or not the damage. It just sees how much would be lethal based on the blocker's toughness (Avacyn's 8) and how much damage is already marked on her (let's say 0), and let's you assign just that much damage to the blocker and the rest to the defending player; things like indestructible and protection just aren't taken in account here.

Then damage is dealt as assigned, 8 to Avacyn and 2 to the player. Avacyn survives, player loses 2 life.

For damage assignment, you only need to assign lethal damage to all blockers before a trampler can assign damage to the defending player or planeswalker.

Lethal damage here means 1+ damage from a creature with deathtouch or enough damage (including present and previously assigned) to equal the toughness of the blocker from creatures without deathtouch.

Avacyn has an 8 toughness, therefore lethal damage (for damage assignment purposes) is at most 8 damage.
Your 10/10 can therefore assign 2 to her.

If Avacyn had already been damaged (say you Bolted her for three earlier this turn) only 5 damage would need to be assigned and you could trample over with 5.

Note: You choose the damage assignment of the 10/10 so you can choose not to have the 2 damage assigned to the defending player and assign it to Avacyn if you like.
eg. you attack Jace (3 loyalty) with a 5/5 trampling doublestriking lifelinker and your opponent blocks with a 1/1, you could trample over with 4 and kill Jace in the first damage step (gaining 5 life) and not strike in the second step or the optimal play would be to assign all 5 to the 1/1 killing it and getting 5 life and then hit Jace in the second step gaining another 5 life and killing him. 

DCI Certified Judge & Goth/Industrial/EBM/Indie/Alternative/80's-Wave DJ
DJ Vortex

DCI Certified Judge since July 13, 2013  - If you have any concerns with my conduct as a judge, feel free to submit feedback here.
DCI #5209514320

My Wife's Makeup Artist Page <-- cool stuff - check it out

Sign In to post comments