I tracked my games over the weekend and found some pretty interesting results. I played 123 games with a random deck (with a few extra games played as GG, PI, ED after the beer kicked in) and put into a spread sheet every deck's wins and losses.
The only deck that came out WAY above or below average was Goblins. Everything else won or lost within 10% points of 50%. I got this figure by applying a won or loss to each deck of each game, so there is a total of 246 data points. For example, if I play BoF and defeat PK, then BoF gets +1 win and PK gets +1 loss. I know this is still small-sample-size territory, but the initial results are encouraging from a balance perspective.
I actually tracked all the games according to matchup, but here are just the final totals.
Edit...updated with info from other players! Thanks!!! Keep sending me info and I'll keep updating.
Now it is a close match between Goblins/OD/BoF with everything else falling into a 2nd Tier and DP being the worst.
|Born of Flame||23||8||6||12||29||20||59.18%|