Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?

What campaign settings would you most like to see printed in D & D Next? Edit: I will only count five campaign settings; if you list more I will PM you and ask if you can reduce your list to five.

Thank you in advance for any votes, responses or feedback. Let's get our vote on!

Edit: I am listing first the results of the polls. Below the results is a non-comprehensive listing of settings. You are not limited to this list, and can vote for what you want to.

Results

Eberron (130): BronzeMonkey, LolaBonne, Crimson_Concerto, TheLyons, Artifact, sciborg3, Seroth, yusakuasano, Zerozobbb, Plaguescarred, Jim11735, jr665, devilMonkey, PaladinNicolas, Salla, Jodymcintyre, tylara67, Warunsun, phaldenby, ShakariLord, Hellcow, balard, GlimmTheGnome, cbirdsong, Belabras, jelmore, Thorin3, Vincentc, Nathallas, Enforcer5981, ReasonForTreason, superdeadsmurf, mhacdebhandia, mrockwell, Joshnumbersbad, Chaltab, LordManshoon, Stormsoul, Ken_of_Ghastria, Veritatis, synthapse, Retina, ChronosCrow, Bobsq2, Ashlock, LonePaladin, Frederyck, Encard, JamesKrolak, sstaunb, Rifter, anony_max, Silver_Blaze, Rotgar, Talae, OskarOisinson, FrozenTime, rethgryn, Orkbard, GrumpyCelt, malisteen, Marandahir, Wizardman, Charlemegne, Traderjodie, Avric_Tholomyes, mantriel, EnderXenocide0, Wed, PJammaGod, Syltorian, SPQRAnarchy, benensky, stevelabny, Accuser, Belisarius19, gothikaiju, Kawnell, GladiusStormhand, TheBoundFenrir, yasuo_takada, Beoric, TimCallahan01, greyghost81, Darrius_Adler, Irennan, cerberuspuppy, skrapsan, rampant, thorzad, Osgood, phuzz, AvonRekaes, Blackbriar, Brazensnow, Vasarto2021, gladiusiv, shyDM, House88, admcewen, Hyomaru, greenfunkman, Luciender, Vim, Wndstar, Uskglass, IGNOREAMOOSE, Monsieur_Moustache, Goddess_Mystra, Lord_Markelhay, oxx, KhanSemus, Uchawi, sgt_d, kilpatds, mrpopstar, SwirlyDragon, Dndungeoneer, Luciender, FoxFireInferno, Lord_Jaroh, Alter_Boy, DDBard1, R0NIN, Oathwin_Oakheart, BranSalisbury, Ashrym, LordVonDerp

Forgotten Realms (115): BronzeMonkey, Butcha, FirstTurnKill, sfdragon, Emperor_Matthaeus, Artifact, Zerozobbb, Zombie_Babies, Jharii, Plaguescarred, Jim11735, Newfie_Keir, Mordaken, erleni, Nicholas_Trandahl, gomeztoo, Jodymcintyre, arderkrag, Spreeth, phaldenby, The_Jester, Aldrein, Ghostrider, Thorin3, Nathallas, mrockwell, nirnel, LordManshoon, Stormsoul, scon40, Bobsq2, Arilon, Ore, Encard, MisterBrix, JamesKrolak, Zach77, Silver_Blaze, BRJN, FrozenTime, Orkbard, Mournblade94, malisteen, Corvus_Metus, RRepster, Wizardman, Grimcarnage, EnderXenocide0, Dethjezter, AddictionMaster, SPQRAnarchy, apartment42, Rian_Lightblade, TheBoundFenrir, Melwick, Mithreinmaethor, Azelmaer, Balfore, CWBush83, mdforbes500, KillerOkane, Irennan, HP2012, Silverque, Krynos_Pentegarn, skrapsan, whimsychris, BillW, smc1977, Eddie_Baron, phuzz, Calithrand, Vasarto2021, gladiusiv, RamirezNerum, Kelsfar, House88, admcewen, Saggoth_Rein, lorddom22, Morbo78, reon79, Falonthas, carldot34, greenfunkman, dekrass, Luciender, D-harhan, Wndstar, Brimleydower, sleypy, Sword_of_Spirit, Goddess_Mystra, FelisLynx, Lord_Markelhay, KhanSemus, sgt_d, Khadrin, loki74, Arius, Traygin, mrpopstar, Maellin, Dndungeoneer, Zardnaar, Luciender, Shemeska_the_Marauder, Lord_Jaroh, GreenKnight, DDBard1, DLfan, professordaddy, R0NIN, BranSalisbury, Eruestan

Planescape (104): BronzeMonkey, Butcha, FirstTurnKill, TheLyons, Emperor_Matthaeus, Tevish_Szat, sciborg3, Azzy1974, yusakuasano, Zerozobbb, Yaeri, Zombie_Babies, blackpol, Mordaken, erleni, devilMonkey, Spreeth, Steely_Dan, phaldenby, The_Jester, ShakariLord, Hellcow, balard, Ghostrider, cbirdsong, Belabras, Vincentc, mhacdebhandia, Joshnumbersbad, Chaltab, Stormsoul, Raddu76, scon40, LonePaladin, Encard, MisterBrix, Rifter, anony_max, Talae, OskarOisinson, rethgryn, Mournblade94, Corvus_Metus, LexBloodSpirit, Agathokles, CATLAND93, EnderXenocide0, Dethjezter, AddictionMaster, Verdegris_Sage, Melwick, yasuo_takada, Octarinewolf, CWBush83, Irennan, cerberuspuppy, Silverque, Hannibal942, Althoroc, LoZeno, DoctorNecrotic, BillW, Pariah74, Osgood, Eagleburger, phuzz, AvonRekaes, DamnedChoir, Calithrand, gladiusiv, RamirezNerum, Drakestar, Talaxar, shyDM, admcewen, Saggoth_Rein, lorddom22, reon79, Falonthas, greenfunkman, souldoubt, areata, Vim, D-harhan, Uskglass, R4Z0RV1N3, Legendarius, ArjenL, Sword_of_Spirit, IGNOREAMOOSE, Monsieur_Moustache, Goddess_Mystra, kill_the_wiz_first, Traygin, Quidhala, mrpopstar, Maellin, SwirlyDragon, Zardnaar, Luciender, Shemeska_the_Marauder, Father-Dagon, GreenKnight, aaronil

Dark Sun (102): BronzeMonkey, Crimson_Concerto, Artifact, Zombie_Babies, Jim11735, Newfie_Keir, Mordaken, Tevish_Szat, sfdragon, devilMonkey, gomeztoo, Jodymcintyre, Alphastream1, tylara67, Warunsun, phaldenby, ShakariLord, GlimmTheGnome, cbirdsong, Thorin3, Vincentc, mhacdebhandia, Joshnumbersbad, nirnel, Chaltab, LordManshoon, Raddu76, DoctorBadWolf, synthapse, ChronosCrow, Bobsq2, Ore, Encard, anony_max, Talae, BRJN, OskarOisinson, Mournblade94, malisteen, RRepster, Marandahir, LexBloodSpirit, CATLAND93, AddictionMaster, Pa11ad1n, Syltorian, apartment42, Belisarius19, Rian_Lightblade, Verdegris_Sage, Mithreinmaethor, yasuo_takada, mdforbes500, TimCallahan01, HP2012, Duskrequim, Hannibal942, skrapsan, Althoroc, rampant, whimsychris, LoZeno, DoctorNecrotic, BillW, smc1977, Pariah74, Eagleburger, phuzz, DamnedChoir, Blackbriar, Brazensnow, Vasarto2021, gladiusiv, Kelsfar, Drakestar, Saggoth_Rein, CrowOfPyke, reon79, Falonthas, greenfunkman, souldoubt, WarfarinKithwood, Wndstar, Uskglass, sleypy, IGNOREAMOOSE, Monsieur_Moustache, Lord_Markelhay, oxx, KhanSemus, loki74, kill_the_wiz_first, Arius, Baalbamoth, kilpatds, mrpopstar, Maellin, Zardnaar, Lord_Jaroh, GreenKnight, R0NIN, BranSalisbury, Ashrym

Ravenloft (97): Butcha, FirstTurnKill, Emperor_Matthaeus, yusakuasano, Zerozobbb, Jharii, blackpol, Daniel-san, Mordaken, Tevish_Szat, MechaPilot, gomeztoo, Jodymcintyre, arderkrag, Steely_Dan, tylara67, ShakariLord, Ghostrider, jelmore, Thorin3, mhacdebhandia, mrockwell, nirnel, Chaltab, LordManshoon, Stormsoul, Ken_of_Ghastria, synthapse, Bobsq2, Ore, Frederyck, MisterBrix, dragonier, Zach77, Silver_Blaze, Rotgar, Orkbard, GrumpyCelt, Corvus_Metus, RRepster, Marandahir, Traderjodie, Avric_Tholomyes, Dethjezter, Pa11ad1n, Syltorian, SPQRAnarchy, Whisspered1, GreenKnight, jfriant, Verdegris_Sage, CWBush83, mdforbes500, Darrius_Adler, HP2012, Duskrequim, DoctorNecrotic, smc1977, Osgood, AvonRekaes, DamnedChoir, RamirezNerum, Kelsfar, Drakestar, Talaxar, Noctivagent, ratchicken, admcewen, Saggoth_Rein, lorddom22, Morbo78, Facet, souldoubt, Vasarto2021, Luciender, WarfarinKithwood, R4Z0RV1N3, Legendarius, Kalex_the_Omen, brap8, ArjenL, IGNOREAMOOSE, Lord_Markelhay, KhanSemus, Xuub, jdnyc, Diffan, The_Jester, Luciender, Shemeska_the_Marauder, Father-Dagon, Lord_Jaroh, DLfan, professordaddy, BranSalisbury, Eruestan, Ashrym

Greyhawk (87): BronzeMonkey, FirstTurnKill, Artifact, sciborg3, Seroth, Phoenix182, Azzy1974, Jharii, Plaguescarred, blackpol, jr665, Tevish_Szat, Nicholas_Trandahl, Jodymcintyre, Alphastream1, arderkrag, Warunsun, Aldrein, Ghostrider, Ken_of_Ghastria, scon40, Frederyck, MisterBrix, JamesKrolak, BRJN, FrozenTime, GrumpyCelt, RRepster, Wizardman, Grimcleaver, EnderXenocide0, Dethjezter, stoloc, apartment42, jfriant, Melwick, Mithreinmaethor, Balfore, HarvestFire, mdforbes500, Oxlar, crazykane, HP2012, Krynos_Pentegarn, skrapsan, Althoroc, whimsychris, Osgood, Eddie_Baron, DSZ, Vasarto2021, RamirezNerum, Doppelgienger, Kelsfar, abanathie, 7he_professor, reon79, Falonthas, Mckalf, Facet, Ivid_IV, Vasarto2021, Luciender, WarfarinKithwood, Wndstar, AtomicPope, Legendarius, Kalex_the_Omen, brap8, ArjenL, Sword_of_Spirit, Monsieur_Moustache, oxx, Uchawi, sgt_d, Khadrin, loki74, kill_the_wiz_first, Steppenwolf41, Traygin, Maellin, almius03, DLfan, professordaddy, R0NIN, Oathwin_Oakheart, Ashrym

Dragonlance (72): TheLyons, Zombie_Babies, Jharii, Plaguescarred, blackpol, Jim11735, Daniel-san, sfdragon, Nicholas_Trandahl, Alphastream1, arderkrag, phaldenby, The_Jester, Ghostrider, Nathallas, mrockwell, Joshnumbersbad, DoctorBadWolf, Arilon, Ore, Zach77, wbbuch, Silver_Blaze, Hlethvagi, FrozenTime, Orkbard, Corvus_Metus, Wizardman, Traderjodie, CATLAND93, AddictionMaster, stoloc, Pa11ad1n, Mithreinmaethor, Balfore, KillerOkane, HP2012, Silverque, Krynos_Pentegarn, whimsychris, BillW, smc1977, thorzad, Eddie_Baron, phuzz, Calithrand, Vasarto2021, Kelsfar, Talaxar, lorddom22, reon79, Falonthas, carldot34, Vasarto2021, Wndstar, Kalex_the_Omen, Sword_of_Spirit, sgt_d, fairytalejedi, Khadrin, loki74, kill_the_wiz_first, Xuub, Arius, jdnyc, mrpopstar, The_Jester, Dndungeoneer, Father-Dagon, almius03, DLfan, Magnificat

Spelljammer (57): TheLyons, Emperor_Matthaeus, Jedi-Wannabe, Tevish_Szat, sciborg3, Seroth, jr665, devilMonkey, Nicholas_Trandahl, Alphastream1, Steely_Dan, ShakariLord, Hellcow, balard, Vincentc, Chaltab, DoctorBadWolf, ChronosCrow, Bobsq2, LonePaladin, Frederyck, MisterBrix, Rifter, Talae, GrumpyCelt, malisteen, RRepster, LexBloodSpirit, EnderXenocide0, AddictionMaster, Pa11ad1n, apartment42, Dunhill, Rian_Lightblade, Verdegris_Sage, GladiusStormhand, Melwick, Octarinewolf, KillerOkane, Irennan, Osgood, AvonRekaes, Talaxar, lorddom22, ViktyrKorimir, WarfarinKithwood, Vim, D-harhan, R4Z0RV1N3, Sword_of_Spirit, Lord_Markelhay, loki74, kilpatds, Dndungeoneer, Zardnaar, professordaddy

Something Brand New (60): jr665, Mordaken, Nicholas_Trandahl, cbirdsong, Vincentc, ReasonForTreason, nirnel, LordManshoon, Raddu76, DoctorBadWolf, Ore, Encard, Rotgar, malisteen, Wizardman, Avric_Tholomyes, Grimcleaver, Pa11ad1n, Wed, SPQRAnarchy, Dunhill, gothikaiju, jfriant, HarvestFire, yasuo_takada, CWBush83, TimCallahan01, greyghost81, KillerOkane, Oxlar, whimsychris, Drakestar, Hyomaru, areata, Vim, DavidArgall, Rizzen9, Uskglass, Legendarius, sleypy, Monsieur_Moustache, Goddess_Mystra, epicfreak, oxx, darkrequiem, fairytalejedi, Khadrin, kill_the_wiz_first, Xuub, Traygin, kilpatds, Diffan, SwirlyDragon, masterfat78, Father-Dagon, Lord_Jaroh, professordaddy, R0NIN, aaronil, Oathwin_Oakheart

Mystara (32): sciborg3, Seroth, Phoenix182, Azzy1974, Plaguescarred, arderkrag, Raddu76, LonePaladin, dragonier, halvgrim, Marandahir, Agathokles, Grimcleaver, jfriant, Rian_Lightblade, Balfore, BillW, smc1977, Pariah74, Eagleburger, Morgasune, carldot34, Facet, Legendarius, ArjenL, sgt_d, Maellin, almius03, DLfan, aaronil, BranSalisbury

Birthright (31): Phoenix182, yusakuasano, Jharii, PaladinNicolas, GlimmTheGnome, Enforcer5981, Ken_of_Ghastria, ChronosCrow, JamesKrolak, Corvus_Metus, Agathokles, Grimcleaver, Syltorian, Balfore, Octarinewolf, cerberuspuppy, Eddie_Baron, Calithrand, Morgasune, Talaxar, dekrass, areata, R4Z0RV1N3, Kalex_the_Omen, fairytalejedi, Traygin, Father-Dagon, GreenKnight, almius03, Oathwin_Oakheart, Magnificat

Al-Qadim (26): Butcha, Zerozobbb, Azzy1974, MechaPilot, gomeztoo, Steely_Dan, Aldrein, mrockwell, Joshnumbersbad, synthapse, Rifter, Mournblade94, LexBloodSpirit, stevelabny, HarvestFire, Octarinewolf, cerberuspuppy, Calithrand, Blackbriar, R4Z0RV1N3, oxx, darkrequiem, fairytalejedi, The_Jester, SwirlyDragon, aaronil

Variant Setting Creation Guidebook (17): Emperor_Matthaeus, Jim11735, Hellcow, nirnel, Talae, BRJN, OskarOisinson, Avric_Tholomyes, stoloc, Syltorian, SPQRAnarchy, gothikaiju, Kawnell, greyghost81, Irennan, Drakestar, darkrequiem

Nentir Vale (19): Artifact, GlimmTheGnome, jelmore, FrozenTime, Marandahir, DoctorBadWolf, Grimcleaver, stoloc, Verdegris_Sage, Azelmaer, skrapsan, carldot34, Luciender, Rizzen9, AH_schulerta, Kalex_the_Omen, sleypy, Luciender, cassi_brazuca, Alter_Boy

Kara-Tur (13): Azzy1974, gomeztoo, Alphastream1, Steely_Dan, Ken_of_Ghastria, Rifter, Mournblade94, gothikaiju, Silverque, carldot34, Uchawi, Xuub, SwirlyDragon

Modern/Future (12): MechaPilot, ChronosCrow, Rotgar, rethgryn, Avric_Tholomyes, greyghost81, DoctorNecrotic, Qmark, Hyomaru, darkrequiem, Alter_Boy, LordVonDerp

Oriental Adventures (11): FirstTurnKill, Phoenix182, blackpol, Aldrein, Rotgar, GrumpyCelt, gothikaiju, HarvestFire, yasuo_takada, darkrequiem, Xuub

Underdark (11): Butcha, devilMonkey, Thorin3, Frederyck, JamesKrolak, Dethjezter, apartment42, CWBush83, Silverque, KhanSemus, Arius

Council of Wyrms (8): TheLyons, crazy_monkey, Dunther_the_Great, Hellcow, balard, Octarinewolf, KillerOkane, Althoroc

Blackmoor (4): dragonier, Rian_Lightblade, Vasarto2021, ArjenL

Savage Coast (3): erleni, dragonier, Agathokles

Kingdoms of Kalamar (3): balard, Mantriel, Krynos_Pentegarn

All Settings (3):Melwick, greyghost81, dnlhl

Ptolus (3): Mantriel, Johnny_Angel, cerberuspuppy

Iomandra (3): Charlemegne, Belisarius19, AvonRekaes

Scarred Lands (3): Krynos_Pentegarn, Eagleburger, Morgasune

Lankhmar (3): Phoenix182, jfriant, mdforbes500

Ghostwalk (3): Aldrein, anony_max, Vasarto2021

3 Musketeers / Pirates of the Caribbean era (4): BRJN, Mantriel, souldoubt, aaronil

Ultramodern (3): Haldrik, SerenaDawn, Dndungeoneer

Dominaria (3): Lord_Jaroh, Alter_Boy, Silver_Blaze

Equestria (2): Qmark, LordVonDerp

Gammaworld (2): Kawnell, Eagleburger

Mahasarpa (2): GlimmTheGnome, mhacdebhandia

Masque of the Red Death (2): synthapse, anony_max

Hollow World (2): dragonier, Agathokles

Maztica (2): LexBloodSpirit, HarvestFire

Thunder Rift (1): Seroth

Fall from Heaven (1): Diavolorosso

Boothill (1): Kawnell

Conversion Docs (1): Kawnell

Domains of Dread (1): Noctivagent

Cybertron (1): Qmark

Paranoia (1): greenfunkman

Shadowfell (1): Uskglass

Immortals (1): areata

Red Steel (1): IGNOREAMOOSE

Taladas (1): Uchawi

Star Wars (1): LordVonDerp 


 

 

Edit 2: Below, I have listed all settings I can find and I have added everything that others have voted on. Any constructive criticism regarding this list is welcomed via post or PM. Remember, this is simply a non-comprehensive list for ideas and you are not in any way limited to this list. I will count anything you vote for and add it to this list.

Al-Qadim
Birthright
Blackmoor
Boothill
Conversion Docs

Council of Wyrms
Cybertron

Dark Sun
Domains of Dread

Dragonlance
Eberron
Equestria

Fall From Heaven
Forgotten Realms
Gammaworld
Ghostwalk

Greyhawk
Hollow World
Jakandor
Kara-Tur
Kingdoms of Kalamar
Lankhmar
Immortals

Iomandra 
Mahasarpa
Masque of the Red Death
Maztica
Modern/Future
Mystara
Nentir Vale
Oriental Adventures
Paranoia

Pelinore
Planescape
Ptolus
Ravenloft
Red Steel
Savage Coast
Scarred Lands
Shadowfell

Something Brand New
Spelljammer
Taladas
Thunder Rift
Ultramodern
Underdark
Wilderlands of High Fantasy
Variant Setting Creation Guidebook
3 Musketeers / Pirates of the Caribbean era

Edit: Changes to list
Removed Rokugan as it is not WotC's IP anymore: Thanks to LolaBonne and FirstTurnKill
Added Variant Setting Creation Guidebook: Thanks to Emperor_Matthaeus
Added Iomandra: Thanks to Plaguescarred 
Added Something Brand New: Thanks to jr665 and Mordaken
Added Modern/Future: Thanks to MechaPilot
Added Ptolus: Thanks to Mantriel
Added Fall From Heaven: Thanks to Diavolorosso
Added 3 Musketeers / Pirates of the Caribbean era: Thanks to BRJN
Added Boothill, Gammaworld and Conversion Docs: Thanks to Kawnell 
Added All Settings: Thanks to Kawnell
Added Scarred Lands: Thanks to Krynos_Pentegarn
Added Domains of Dread: Thanks to Noctivagent
Added Cybertron and Equestria: Thanks to Qmark
Added Paranoia: Thanks to greenfunkman
Added Ultramodern: Thanks to Haldrik
Added Immortals: Thanks to areata
Added Shadowfell: Thanks to Uskglass
Added Red Steel: Thanks to IGNOREAMOOSE
Added Taladas: Thanks to Uchawi 

Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?
I would pick Greyhawk and Forgotten Realms for traditional core.  For the more off-beat, I would pick Planescape, Eberron and Dark Sun.
1) Forgotten Realms

2) Planescape

3) Underdark

4) Ravenloft

5) Al-Qadim         


The Character Initiative


Every time you abuse the system you enforce limitations.
Every time the system is limited we lose options.
Breaking an RPG is like cheating in a computer game.
As a DM you are the punkbuster of your table.
Dare to say no to abusers.
Make players build characters, not characters out of builds.




Eberron.

Yep, that's it.  I doubt I'd spend money on anything else on that list.
In 3e Oriental Adventures was Rokugan...are you meaning something different between the two?

Anyway, my choices:

Planescape
Greyhawk
Forgotten Realms
Ravenloft
Oriental Adventures

Somnia, the Evanescent Plane -- A 3-set Block
Set 1 — Somnia
Set 2 — TBD
Set 3 — TBD
Planeswalker's Guide to Somnia

Build Around This
A weekly MTG Cards and Combos forum game.
Build Around This #1 - Sage's Starfish Wish
BAT #1 was built using the Legacy format with Spiny Starfish, Sage's Knowledge, and Make a Wish. Winner: Dilleux_Lepaire with Fishy Starfishies. Runner-Up: JBTM
Dark Sun
Eberron

They're the only campaign settings I've ever been excited to play in. After that, I'd like to see some new ideas rather than the same old thing repeated over and over (I'm so sick and tired of Forgotten Realms). Though, there are a few on this list that I don't know enough about and might be willing to try out given more info: Al-Qadim, Dragonlance, Hollow World, Kara-Tur, and especially Spelljammer.

Why, yes, as a matter of fact I am the Unfailing Arbiter of All That Is Good Design (Even More So Than The Actual Developers) TM Speaking of things that were badly designed, please check out this thread for my Minotaur fix. What have the critics said, you ask? "If any of my players ask to play a Minotaur, I'm definitely offering this as an alternative to the official version." - EmpactWB "If I ever feel like playing a Minotaur I'll know where to look!" - Undrave "WoTC if you are reading this - please take this guy's advice." - Ferol_Debtor_of_Torm "Really full of win. A minotaur that is actually attractive for more than just melee classes." - Cpt_Micha Also, check out my recent GENASI variant! If you've ever wished that your Fire Genasi could actually set stuff on fire, your Water Genasi could actually swim, or your Wind Genasi could at least glide, then look no further. Finally, check out my OPTIONS FOR EVERYONE article, an effort to give unique support to the races that WotC keeps forgetting about. Includes new racial feature options for the Changeling, Deva, Githzerai, Gnoll, Gnome, Goliath, Half-Orc, Kalashtar, Minotaur, Shadar-Kai, Thri-Kreen, Warforged and more!
forgotten realms
a mask everyone has at least two of, one they wear in public and another they wear in private.....
Planescape
Council of Wyrms
Dragonlance
Eberron
Spelljammer

Elaboration - I am only elaborating on two settings

Planescape - In my opinion, this is the most creative and entertaining campaign setting of all time. There is so much story and flavor in this campaign it's hard to sum up. In the right DM's hands, this campaign setting was very engaging and entertaining regardless of other factors. I find this campaign just as engrossing and challenging for level 1 characters as it is for level 30 characters. I have long been obsessed with this campaign setting!

Council of Wyrms - I feel this campaign setting is not well-known and thus underrated. This setting allowed players to play dragons and was suited to the unique challenges and "adventures" that dragons would likely experience. It definitely was a nice change of pace to occasionally play this setting.
Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?
In 3e Oriental Adventures was Rokugan...are you meaning something different between the two?



That one I wasn't sure if I should separate out or not, as well as a few other settings I have listed as well. Should a vote for Rokugan be counted different than one for Oriental Adventures itself? Honestly, I am going with the opinions of those that give one or vote on those settings as OA and Rokugan may be better considered the same setting.
Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?
In 3e Oriental Adventures was Rokugan...are you meaning something different between the two?



That one I wasn't sure if I should separate out or not, as well as a few other settings I have listed as well. Should a vote for Rokugan be counted different than one for Oriental Adventures itself? Honestly, I am going with the opinions of those that give one or vote on those settings as OA and Rokugan may be better considered the same setting.



Oriental Adventures was a basic 'theme book'.
Kara-Tur was the campaign setting that used the rules in the OA book (later wiggled into Forgotten Realms).
Rokugan is no longer WotC's IP and is not really an option (it has reverted to AEG).
In 3e Oriental Adventures was Rokugan...are you meaning something different between the two?



That one I wasn't sure if I should separate out or not, as well as a few other settings I have listed as well. Should a vote for Rokugan be counted different than one for Oriental Adventures itself? Honestly, I am going with the opinions of those that give one or vote on those settings as OA and Rokugan may be better considered the same setting.


Well, Rokugan isn't WotC's IP, as it's the Legend of the Five Rings setting.  I would honestly not even include it on this list, except perhaps as an example of an Oriental Adventures setting, like so:

Oriental Adventures (ex. Rokugan)

It's possible that even if it were the most popular setting, WotC still would not be able to obtain a publishing rights deal again.  But that doesn't invalidate the idea that a uniquely Oriental setting may be desired, it just might have to be a new one.

Somnia, the Evanescent Plane -- A 3-set Block
Set 1 — Somnia
Set 2 — TBD
Set 3 — TBD
Planeswalker's Guide to Somnia

Build Around This
A weekly MTG Cards and Combos forum game.
Build Around This #1 - Sage's Starfish Wish
BAT #1 was built using the Legacy format with Spiny Starfish, Sage's Knowledge, and Make a Wish. Winner: Dilleux_Lepaire with Fishy Starfishies. Runner-Up: JBTM
1. Forgotten Realms
2. Planescape
3. Ravenloft
4. Spelljammer
5. Rules/guidelines/suggestions for designing our own variant settings---from Western to sci-fi to 1920s crime thriller to anything in-between. 
Greyhawk was one of the very first D&D worlds.  DDN will be an 'anniversary edition', so Greyhawk as a published setting (not merely an assumed setting as in 3e) makes sense I think.

Forgotten Realms, Eberron, and Dark Sun are others that I wouldn't wanna be without.

Nentir Vale would be my choice for an assumed setting (same as in 4e).

/\ Art
Rokugan is no longer WotC's IP and is not really an option (it has reverted to AEG).



Well, Rokugan isn't WotC's IP, as it's the Legend of the Five Rings setting.



Thank you for that information. I had no idea Rokugan wasn't WotC's IP anymore. IMO that is in and of itself enough reason to remove it from the list.
Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?
Al-Qadim
Eberron
Forgotten Realms
Greyhawk
Kara-Tur
Maztica
Mystara
Oriental Adventures
Planescape
Ravenloft
Savage Coast
Spelljammer
Underdark

I've used most of these at some point in the past, and those I haven't are ones I admire. I'd also like to see a more solidly Earth-Medieval setting, and a new fully-fantastical setting.

Z.
What campaign settings would you most like to see reprinted in D & D Next? I will only count the first five campaign settings you list, no matter how many you list. Feel free to elaborate on why you want to see your chosen settings reprinted if you desire. This is obviously not a requirement for the poll; elaboration is a courtesy to generate feedback for the game designers.

There are other threads on this topic, although I am unable to find one listed as a "poll". I am not counting material in those threads as votes in this thread. However, I do hope posters in similar threads share their opinions in this poll.

Below, I have listed all settings I could find. Please let me know of any setting(s) I do not have in this list as I very well could have made a mistake or inadvertently omitted a setting. Any constructive criticism/comments/concerns/etc about the list are appreciated, but it should be noted that many will likely have differing opinions and it is unlikely to create or even refine a list that will strike everyone as accurate and comprehensive.


Al-Qadim
Birthright
Blackmoor
Council of Wyrms
Dark Sun
Dragonlance
Eberron
Forgotten Realms
Ghostwalk
Greyhawk
Hollow World
Jakandor
Kara-Tur
Kingdoms of Kalamar
Lankhmar
Mahasarpa
Masque of the Red Death
Maztica
Mystara
Nentir Vale
Oriental Adventures
Pelinore
Planescape
Ravenloft
Savage Coast
Spelljammer
Thunder Rift
Underdark
Wilderlands of High Fantasy
Variant Setting Creation Guidebook

Edit: Changes to list
Removed Rokugan as it is not WotC's IP anymore
Added Variant Setting Creation Guidebook (idea by Emperor_Matthaeus)


There are many, many ways to organize a list of campaign settings. I made an attempt to list more rather than less in hopes of receiving more specific feedback for the game designers. A conversation about what campaign(s) should or should not be combined may be deemed important and if so we could start a whole new thread on that topic alone. Keep in mind, it will likely be a hotly debated topic.

Example: Should the Underdark be considered its own setting or as part of another campaign? The Underdark is often associated with Forgotten Realms, however, the Underdark was part of Greyhawk years before Forgotten Realms was printed. Furthermore, the Underdark was described in great detail without reference to another setting in the Dungeoneer's Survival Guide in 1986 (AMAZING book), a full year before the first Forgotten Realms book was even printed! Personally, I think where the Underdark does or does not belong is a decision each DM should make for his or her campaign setting(s).

Thank you in advance for any votes, responses or feedback. Let's get our vote on!


Al-Qadim (1): Butcha

Birthright

Blackmoor

Council of Wyrms (1): TheLyons

Dark Sun (3): BronzeMonkey, Crimson_Concerto, Artifact

Dragonlance (1): TheLyons

Eberron (5): BronzeMonkey, LolaBonne, Crimson_Concerto, TheLyons, Artifact

Forgotten Realms (6): BronzeMonkey, Butcha, FirstTurnKill, sfdragon, Emperor_Matthaeus, Artifact

Ghostwalk

Greyhawk (3): BronzeMonkey, FirstTurnKill, Artifact

Hollow World

Jakandor

Kara-Tur

Kingdoms of Kalamar


Lankhmar


Mahasarpa


Masque of the Red Death


Maztica


Mystara


Nentir Vale
(1): Artifact

Oriental Adventures
(1): FirstTurnKill

Pelinore


Planescape
(5): BronzeMonkey, Butcha, FirstTurnKill, TheLyons, Emperor_Matthaeus

Ravenloft
(3): Butcha, FirstTurnKill, Emperor_Matthaeus

Savage Coast

Spelljammer
(2): TheLyons, Emperor_Matthaeus

Thunder Rift

Underdark (1): Butcha

Wilderlands of High Fantasy

Variant Setting Creation Guidebook
(1): Emperor_Matthaeus

Spelljammer.

There are others I'd like to see return, but given how things went with FR in 4th, I don't want to see WOTC handle them.
Planescape and Spelljammer, all the way.

"Enjoy your screams, Sarpadia - they will soon be muffled beneath snow and ice."
On Worldbuilding - On Crafting Aliens - Pillars of Art and Flavor - Simulationism, Narritivism, and Gamism - Shub-Niggurath in D&D
THE COALITION WAR GAME -Phyrexian Chief Praetor
Round 1: (4-1-2, 1 kill)
Round 2: (16-8-2, 4 kills)
Round 3: (18-9-2, 1 kill)
Round 4: (22-10-0, 2 kills)
Round 5: (56-16-3, 9 kills)
Round 6: (8-7-1)

Last Edited by Ralph on blank, 1920

I'd wish to see:

Dragonlance
Eberron
Forgotten Realms (including Kara-tur, Al Quadim and Mulhorandi)
Greyhawk (including Blackmoore)
Mystara


and a special off the record mention to:
Iomandra 

Yan
Montréal, Canada
@Plaguescarred on twitter

Planescape
Spelljammer

Eberron
Greyhawk
Mystara
I´ll love to see the following

Greyhawk

Mystara (with Hollow World of course!)

Spelljammer

Eberron 

For an assumed setting I prefer the old Thunder Rift.
Greyhawk
Planescape
Mystara
I don't care what campaign settings come out as long as they are varied, frequent, and numerous. I have nothing against Forgotten Realms and Eberron, but they were the only campaign settings published for 3e and they both had a huge amount of material published for them, which kind of felt like a slap in the face to people who were interested in seeing more new settings, or wanted to see more of the older settings updated.

There was Dragonlance which had a single book not updated to 3.5 and then Wheel of Time which technically wasn't even D&D and it was a tad disappointing to see both of them immediately abandoned.

Also, like I said I don't dislike Forgotten Realms, but I do think it is massively, immensely overrated. It's not really very creative, it feels like the normal default setting plus a few extra rules. It's "epic high fantasy", and is everything you'd expect from that phrase. Predictable, safe, reliable, you know what you're gonna get.
Planescape
Birthright
Ravenloft
Eberron

That is the order. I am huge Planescape fan, and i am still using my Birthright books for inspiration for my homebrew campaign.
Ravenloft is probably the setting that i have played most as a player. Also i enjoy (as a player again) the political - fantasy noir world of Eberron. 
If I have to pick just five, those five are:

Al-Qadim
Eberron
Forgotten Realms
Planescape
Ravenloft

To be honest, it would be good if the core rules supported Oriental Adventures style material straight off.

Z.
I want them to either give planescape a new edition treatment or just reprint the old 2nd edition planescape like they are doing with 1st edition core now.
Should I make grammar mistakes, I am most likely unaware of them. Feel free to point them out lest I keep making them. I shall take no offense.
I want them to either give planescape a new edition treatment or just reprint the old 2nd edition planescape like they are doing with 1st edition core now.



I agree with you wholeheartedly. Either way you mentioned or even a combination could work. The 2e Planescape materials are absolutely incredible. In fact, I still use them in my games regardless of the edition of rules I am running at the time.
Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?
1. Forgotten Realms
2. Dragonlance
3. Dark Sun
4. Ravenloft
5. Planescape

They can leave the rest, really.  I mean, there's others that I've enjoyed but these are my top five for a reason.
Resident Prophet of the OTTer.

Section Six Soldier

Front Door of the House of Trolls

[b]If you're terribly afraid of your character dying, it may be best if you roleplayed something other than an adventurer.[/b]

Ranked in order of what I would like to see in 5E with my overall ranking in parenthesis.

1. Dragonlance (2)
2. Birthright (3)
3. Ravenloft (5)
4. Forgotten Realms (1)
5. Greyhawk (4)

99. Eberron (99)   

Reflavoring: the change of flavor without changing any mechanical part of the game, no matter how small, in order to fit the mechanics to an otherwise unsupported concept. Retexturing: the change of flavor (with at most minor mechanical adaptations) in order to effortlessly create support for a concept without inventing anything new. Houseruling: the change, either minor or major, of the mechanics in order to better reflect a certain aspect of the game, including adapting the rules to fit an otherwise unsupported concept. Homebrewing: the complete invention of something new that fits within the system in order to reflect an unsupported concept. Default module =/= Core mechanic.
my choices would have to be

Greyhawk
Dragonlance
Planescape
Ravenloft
OA

but of my choices, primarely Greyhawk

html_removed html_removed
html_removed
html_removed
Variant Setting Creation Guidebook

Eberron

Dragonlance

Dark Sun

Forgotten Realms

Heck, I'll ammend my vote to include Al-Qadim and Kara-Tur... Both fun settings. I just hope that the core rules are culturally inclusive enogh that there doesn't need to be expasions to run these sort of settings.

Also... Oriental Adventures setting? THe setting in the 1e OA was Kara-Tur (which was later expanded through modules and the stting boxed ste). The one in the 3e OA was Rokugan (which WotC no longer has rights to).
Al Quadim & Kara Tur (but done right)
Forgotten Realms
Ebberon
Underdark
Mistara
Birthright

Edit:
Dragonlance
Ravenloft
Dark Sun & Forgotten Realms

  1. Dragonlance

  2. Ravenloft


The first is a classic and got some superb material for 3.5 (made by MWP), also has a great novel support.


The second is just great for Dark Fantasy/horror themed campaign.

1. Greyhawk
2. Spelljammer
3. Eberron
4. Something completly NEW!!! 
I will post 5, but I have a few concerns about the list.

Darksun
Planescape
Raveloft

Those are the three 'worlds' that should be published. Below is a list of things that should be printed,a nd printed correctly as a group.

Forgotten Realms -- which includes Maztica, Kara-Tur was the East part of Faerun, and I belive Al-Qaddim was the deep south part, and all three I belive is in one of the maps of Torril at one point. Why they have become seperated in the eyes of others I will never understand. They all exists within the same planet and should be considered one.
 
My last Vote, goes to the an all new setting, and when I mean all new I don't mean Ebberon, which was from the outset was doomed to be very similar to FR, and shouldn't have been. I like Ebberon, but I was hoping for a different world, not a different flavor of a world. 
Those are the three 'worlds' that should be published. Below is a list of things that should be printed,a nd printed correctly as a group.

Forgotten Realms -- which includes Maztica, Kara-Tur was the East part of Faerun, and I belive Al-Qaddim was the deep south part, and all three I belive is in one of the maps of Torril at one point. Why they have become seperated in the eyes of others I will never understand. They all exists within the same planet and should be considered one.



By listing them separately I am not actually implying one setting is separate from another. One voting for Al-Qadim may be noting that aspects of Al-Qadim are very important to them. Looking at the results, two have specifically voted for Al-Qadim and those two also voted for Forgotten Realms. Perhaps they rather enjoy Al-Qadim and I feel that is important feedback for the game designers. Whether Al-Qadim is a separate campaign setting from Forgotten Realms is based on how the DM runs their game really.

Some settings get even more tricky regarding what is part of what. Underdark is often associated with Forgotten Realms, but was part of Greyhawk long before it was part of FR. Also, it was developed as a stand alone type setting (or at least setting neutral) in the Dungeoneer's Survival Guide in 1986, one year before FR even existed. As Azzy1974 points out, Kara-tur was part of Oriental Adventures as well.

I am curious about who thinks what should be part of what else, and was thinking of starting a whole new thread for it eventually unless someone else does first.
Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?
Plenescape, Savage Coast and Forgotten Realms.

IMAGE(http://www.nodiatis.com/pub/23.jpg)

I only picked 2 before, and while those two, Planescape and Spelljammer, are the most important for me (especially planescape) I might as well round out the top 5

Ravenloft, Dark Sun, Greyhawk.


Each of these 5 represents a major genre.  In reverse-order

Greyhawk: Represents the Standard Fantasy Setting of Sword and Sorcery.  This might be able to be filled by FR, but I'd prefer Greyhawk.  It might be able to be filled by Birthright, but I'll admit I'm not familiar with Birthright.  Mystara is a little... strange if I recall.

Dark Sun: Post Apocalypse/World-is-trying-to-kill-you adventuring.  Dark Sun is the ultimate campaign setting for gritty.

Ravenloft: Horror.  Horror games can be very fun, and Ravenloft is the setting custom made to support them

Spelljammer: Science Fiction Fantasy.  It's niche, but it's a ton of fun.  Interestingly, I would set Eberron mostly in the same niche, due to Eberron's high levels of magitech.  However, Eberron doesn't fulfill the role NEARLY as well as Spelljammer does

Planescape: Planescape is Weird, Epic, and what's more, it's something that is really pure D&D.  It's the metaverse of Dungeons and Dragons lore without the need for outside forces weighing on it.  And yet, it's so different!  Planescape is philosophical and cerebral (without cutting off opportunities to bash monsters), and the Wheel is so big that it lends itself very handily to multiple campaigns.

"Enjoy your screams, Sarpadia - they will soon be muffled beneath snow and ice."
On Worldbuilding - On Crafting Aliens - Pillars of Art and Flavor - Simulationism, Narritivism, and Gamism - Shub-Niggurath in D&D
THE COALITION WAR GAME -Phyrexian Chief Praetor
Round 1: (4-1-2, 1 kill)
Round 2: (16-8-2, 4 kills)
Round 3: (18-9-2, 1 kill)
Round 4: (22-10-0, 2 kills)
Round 5: (56-16-3, 9 kills)
Round 6: (8-7-1)

Last Edited by Ralph on blank, 1920


By listing them separately I am not actually implying one setting is separate from another. One voting for Al-Qadim may be noting that aspects of Al-Qadim are very important to them. Looking at the results, two have specifically voted for Al-Qadim and those two also voted for Forgotten Realms. Perhaps they rather enjoy Al-Qadim and I feel that is important feedback for the game designers. Whether Al-Qadim is a separate campaign setting from Forgotten Realms is based on how the DM runs their game really.

Some settings get even more tricky regarding what is part of what. Underdark is often associated with Forgotten Realms, but was part of Greyhawk long before it was part of FR. Also, it was developed as a stand alone type setting (or at least setting neutral) in the Dungeoneer's Survival Guide in 1986, one year before FR even existed. As Azzy1974 points out, Kara-tur was part of Oriental Adventures as well.

I am curious about who thinks what should be part of what else, and was thinking of starting a whole new thread for it eventually unless someone else does first.



While I understand that they can be sepearted and I was going to mention that the Underdark is also a region found in several setting, but felt, I had my point. Choosing 5 and having 3 of them all be included in one setting really limits one choices.

And why we are speaking of histories I noticed a lot of people saying Rokugan is no longer a part of WotC, I think it should be mentioned that they just don't have the rights to print rules for it, as it has always been a part of the L5R universe. Dragonlance is still listed even though WotC does not have the rights to print that world either. Though in both cases I am sure a deal could be made again (though I would prefer Rokugan over Dragonlance). 

While I understand that they can be sepearted and I was going to mention that the Underdark is also a region found in several setting, but felt, I had my point. Choosing 5 and having 3 of them all be included in one setting really limits one choices.



You are correct, but that's also the reason I made it that way. If someone votes for Forgotten Realms AND Al-Qadim (instead of voting on something else) that is an interesting and noteworthy detail. In fact, the fact that Al-Qadim has been getting these votes even by those also voting for FR makes me personally curious to check out Al-Qadim books and see what is in there.


And why we are speaking of histories I noticed a lot of people saying Rokugan is no longer a part of WotC, I think it should be mentioned that they just don't have the rights to print rules for it, as it has always been a part of the L5R universe. Dragonlance is still listed even though WotC does not have the rights to print that world either. Though in both cases I am sure a deal could be made again (though I would prefer Rokugan over Dragonlance). 



I've been thinking about how we should to do that, and what should be removed from the list. So far, no one's actually listed Rokugan as a vote and if they did I'd certainly add it back to the list to count their vote. Many (myself included) have voted for Dragonlance, and if WotC doesn't own the IP I hope they get it back! I wouldn't feel right about removing something from the list that someone's voted on and I've been adding what extra people have been voting on regardless of what it is. IMO, any vote is worth counting.

I wish there was a "best" way that everyone would agree to be accurate and comprehensive. There's not. However, I think there are a lot worse ways I could have done it!

I do appreciate your feedback.
Do you have an opinion on what campaign settings should be printed in D&D Next? If so, please cast your votes in this poll! Poll: What campaign settings do you want to see printed in D&D Next?